Question

Difficulty: MediumSupporting Claims with Evidence and Details

The following sentences are from a draft of an essay about Maya engineering. To ensure that the paragraph logically builds its claim that Maya engineering successfully addressed water scarcity, in what order should these sentences be placed?

  1. 1Many ancient Maya cities were built far from natural rivers, forcing builders to design sophisticated systems to collect and preserve water.
  2. 2At the city of Tikal, engineers excavated massive reservoirs from limestone quarries and lined them with plaster to prevent seepage.
  3. 3These plaster-lined basins were connected to a series of paved canals, which channeled seasonal rainwater directly from public plazas into the reservoirs.
  4. 4Consequently, these engineered reservoirs held enough water to support a population of tens of thousands of residents throughout the dry season.

Answer

The logical order of the sentences is: the sentence establishing the general water scarcity problem, followed by the sentence introducing the reservoirs at Tikal, then the sentence detailing the canal connections to those basins, and concluding with the sentence stating the population supported by the system.
The paragraph begins with the general claim that Maya cities built far from rivers required sophisticated water management systems. It then provides the concrete example of the reservoirs at Tikal, which were lined with plaster. The next sentence builds on this detail by explaining how 'these plaster-lined basins' were filled using paved canals. Finally, the paragraph concludes with the result of this system—that it successfully supported tens of thousands of residents throughout the dry season.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the main claim or introductory statement of the paragraph.
The sentence stating that many ancient Maya cities were built far from natural rivers, forcing them to design sophisticated water systems, functions as the introductory claim.
Paragraphs typically begin with a broad claim or context before introducing specific examples and detailed evidence.
2
Locate the specific evidence that introduces the main example supporting the claim.
The sentence introducing the plaster-lined reservoirs at the city of Tikal provides the first concrete example of the water systems.
This sentence shifts the focus from a general claim about Maya cities to a specific, illustrative case study.
3
Use cohesive devices and pronoun references to connect the next detail to the example.
The sentence describing how 'these plaster-lined basins' were connected to paved canals must follow the introduction of the plaster-lined reservoirs.
The demonstrative phrase 'these plaster-lined basins' directly references the 'reservoirs... lined with plaster' mentioned in the previous sentence.
4
Identify the sentence that details the final outcome or result of the system.
The sentence starting with 'Consequently' describes the ultimate impact of the reservoirs (supporting tens of thousands of residents).
The transition word 'Consequently' signals a concluding result, which logically summarizes the effectiveness of the entire engineered system.

Key Concept

Supporting Claims with Evidence and Details
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question