Question

Difficulty: HardConnotation and Tone of Words in Context

For decades, critics dismissed Wharton’s early novels as mere *domestic* chronicles, assuming that her focus on the drawing rooms of New York’s elite precluded any serious engagement with the broader human condition. Yet this label overlooks the subtle irony that pervades her descriptions of social rituals.

Which of the following most nearly describes the connotation of the word *domestic* as it is used in the first sentence of the passage?

  1. A
    native rather than foreign
  2. B
    cozy and family-centered
  3. trivial and intellectually narrowAnswer
  4. D
    submissive and obedient

Answer

trivial and intellectually narrow
The correct option is correct because, in the context of the passage, critics are dismissing Wharton's novels as 'mere domestic chronicles.' The word 'mere' and the contrast with the 'broader human condition' indicate that 'domestic' carries a negative, limiting connotation. The critics believe that because Wharton's stories take place within the household and social spheres of the elite, they are trivial and intellectually narrow.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the target word in the first sentence of the passage and analyze its immediate context.
The target word is 'domestic', which is modified by 'mere' and used by critics to dismiss Wharton's novels because they focus on 'drawing rooms' rather than the 'broader human condition'.
To understand the connotation, we must identify how the word is being used and the attitude of the speakers (the critics) using it.
2
Determine the tone and connotation implied by the critics' description.
The word 'mere' indicates a dismissive, condescending tone. The contrast with the 'broader human condition' suggests that the critics view 'domestic' chronicles as limited, petty, or lacking in intellectual depth.
This establishes that the correct option must carry a negative, limiting connotation that aligns with this dismissive tone.
3
Evaluate the answer choices against this determined connotation.
The option 'trivial and intellectually narrow' aligns perfectly with the critics' view that the novels lack broad human significance. Other options either misinterpret the tone as positive, use unrelated dictionary definitions, or confuse 'domestic' with 'domesticated'.
This allows us to select the correct meaning and eliminate the distractors.

Key Concept

Connotation and Tone of Words in Context
Rate this question