Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardEvaluating Narrator Reliability and Bias

Although I have always championed the historical integrity of our downtown district, I could not support the Preservation Society’s campaign to halt the demolition of the old Millstone Granary. True, it was erected in 1884, but it has stood as a hollow, structurally compromised eyesore for decades, contributing nothing to our community's modernization efforts. The Society, led by the obstinate and sentimental Clara Vance, claimed the building represented our town’s agrarian roots, but they ignored the report by Vance & Associates Engineers—which Clara’s own cousin manages—warning that the foundation was shifting precariously. When the city council voted to replace the granary with the new Meridian Commerce Center, Clara accused us of selling our heritage to the highest bidder. But the council's decision was purely pragmatic: we needed a modern hub to attract tech startups, which would revitalize our local economy. The fact that my own real estate firm, Miller & Sons, was selected to lease the commercial suites in the new development is entirely incidental; our bid was objectively the most competitive, and our primary concern has always been the public welfare. Clara's public insinuations about conflict of interest are merely the desperate deflections of a preservationist who has lost touch with the practical realities of progress.

Which of the following aspects of the passage provides the strongest evidence of the narrator's lack of objectivity regarding the demolition of the Millstone Granary?

  1. The narrator's dismissing his own real estate firm's financial involvement in the new development while using familial relationships to undermine Clara Vance's credibility.Answer
  2. B
    The narrator's assertion that the granary has been a hollow, structurally compromised eyesore for decades.
  3. C
    The narrator's explanation that the city council decided to demolish the granary in order to attract tech startups and revitalize the economy.
  4. D
    The narrator's conclusion that Clara Vance is a sentimental preservationist who has lost touch with practical realities.

Answer

The narrator's dismissing his own real estate firm's financial involvement in the new development while using familial relationships to undermine Clara Vance's credibility.
The correct answer identifies the double standard at the core of the narrator's argument: he dismisses his own firm's direct financial connection to the new project as 'entirely incidental,' yet attempts to discredit Clara Vance by highlighting that her cousin manages the engineering firm. This discrepancy in how he evaluates conflicts of interest directly demonstrates his lack of objectivity and bias.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the narrator's self-interest in the situation.
The narrator reveals that his own real estate firm, Miller & Sons, was selected to lease the commercial suites in the new Meridian Commerce Center.
Establishing the narrator's personal financial stake is crucial to identifying potential bias.
2
Identify the double standard the narrator uses to discredit his opponent.
The narrator attempts to discredit Clara Vance by pointing out that her cousin manages the engineering firm that wrote the structural report, implying a conflict of interest, while simultaneously claiming his own firm's selection was purely incidental and competitive.
Comparing how the narrator treats similar conflicts of interest (his own vs. Clara's) highlights his lack of objectivity.
3
Evaluate which option represents this structural bias.
The choice describing the contrast between the narrator's dismissal of his own conflict of interest and his highlighting of Clara's family ties accurately identifies the evidence of bias.
Selecting the option that identifies the narrator's logical double standard demonstrates mastery of evaluating narrator reliability.

Key Concept

Evaluating Narrator Reliability and Bias
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Evaluating Narrator Reliability and Bias

More questions from this topic