Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasySummarizing Key Thesis and Central Arguments

Historically, historians believed that the ancient Silk Road was solely a commercial highway for luxury goods like silk and spices. However, recent archaeological findings suggest that its most significant impact was actually the transmission of agricultural technologies.

Initially, excavations revealed that eastern crops, such as rice and peaches, began appearing in western markets much earlier than previously recorded. This discovery challenged the traditional view of the route as a simple merchant path, indicating a deeper ecological exchange. Furthermore, research showed that these crops did not just travel as cargo; instead, farming techniques and irrigation methods were systematically adopted by local communities along the route. Ultimately, this agricultural exchange permanently transformed the diets and farming landscapes of both East Asia and the Mediterranean, establishing the Silk Road as a catalyst for global environmental change rather than a mere trade route.

Based on the passage, what is the correct order of the steps of the author's central argument, from the initial premise to the final conclusion?

  1. 1The author presents the traditional historical consensus that the Silk Road functioned primarily as a commercial channel for luxury goods.
  2. 2The author introduces new archaeological findings showing early crop appearances to dispute the commercial-only view.
  3. 3The author explains that the exchange involved the active adoption of farming and irrigation techniques, not just the transport of goods.
  4. 4The author concludes that the Silk Road's primary legacy is its role as a driver of permanent, global environmental transformation.

Answer

The correct order begins with the traditional consensus about the Silk Road's commercial nature, followed by the introduction of crop evidence challenging this view, then the explanation of the active adoption of farming methods, and concludes with the thesis that the route drove global environmental change.
The correct order follows the logical development of the author's argument. First, the author establishes the traditional belief that the Silk Road was a commercial trade route. Next, the author introduces new crop evidence that challenges this traditional view. Then, the author details the active integration of agricultural techniques by local communities. Finally, the author presents the central thesis: the Silk Road acted as a driver of permanent, global ecological transformation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the starting point of the argument.
The traditional view that the Silk Road was solely a commercial highway for luxury goods.
The author starts by establishing the common historical assumption in order to set up the counterargument.
2
Identify the initial counter-evidence presented.
The discovery of eastern crops appearing in the west earlier than expected.
This serves as the first piece of evidence to challenge the commercial-only narrative.
3
Identify how the author elaborates on the counter-evidence.
The explanation that communities adopted farming and irrigation techniques, showing a deeper exchange.
This shows the mechanism of the agricultural transmission, demonstrating it went beyond mere trade.
4
Identify the final thesis or conclusion.
The characterization of the Silk Road as a catalyst for global environmental change.
This is the final synthesis of the argument, summarizing the central thesis.

Key Concept

Structuring and sequencing the development of a central argument.
Rate this question

Topics

Summarizing Key Thesis and Central Arguments

More questions from this topic