Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumAnalyzing Tone and Attitude

For centuries, cartography was as much an exercise in artistic imagination as it was in geographical measurement. Mapmakers of the Renaissance filled the vast, unexplored spaces of the oceans with detailed illustrations of mythical sea monsters and elaborate wind roses, signaling not a lack of scientific rigor to their contemporaries, but rather a holistic view of the cosmos where art and science were inextricably linked. However, by the mid-eighteenth century, the rise of systematic triangulation and the demands of imperial navigation ushered in an era of austere precision. To these new, mathematically minded surveyors, the decorative embellishments of their predecessors were not merely superfluous; they were a dangerous distraction, a cluttering of the state's geopolitical reality with whimsical falsehoods. Yet, in their rush to strip the map of its monsters, these modern cartographers also stripped it of its narrative, transforming the map from a storytelling canvas into a sterile instrument of control.

Which of the following best describes the author's attitude toward the transition from Renaissance cartography to modern surveying methods?

  1. Disapproving of the sterile, purely functional nature of modern maps at the expense of artistic storytellingAnswer
  2. B
    Enthusiastic about the technological progress and safety improvements brought by systematic triangulation
  3. C
    Indifferent, presenting a purely historical comparison of the two mapping eras without taking a stance
  4. D
    Whimsical, expressing a desire to restore mythical creatures to contemporary navigation charts

Answer

Disapproving of the sterile, purely functional nature of modern maps at the expense of artistic storytelling
The author expresses a clear critical stance in the final sentence of the passage, noting that the modern cartographers 'stripped [the map] of its narrative' and transformed it into a 'sterile instrument of control.' This language shows disapproval of the shift toward pure functionality at the expense of the storytelling aspect of mapmaking.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the passage to locate the author's voice and commentary on the shift from Renaissance cartography to modern surveying.
The author describes Renaissance cartography in positive, complex terms ('holistic view', 'storytelling canvas') and describes modern surveying in stark, negative terms ('sterile instrument of control', 'stripped it of its narrative').
Identifying the contrasting descriptions allows us to gauge the author's subjective stance on the transition.
2
Evaluate the author's concluding sentence, which contains the key tone indicator.
The final sentence uses critical language ('rush to strip', 'sterile instrument') to evaluate the consequences of the modern approach.
The conclusion of a passage often contains the author's synthesis and explicit evaluation of the subject matter.
3
Match the identified critical tone to the best-fitting option.
The correct option correctly identifies the author's disapproval of the sterile nature of modern mapping.
This option aligns with the author's focus on the loss of artistic storytelling and narrative.

Key Concept

Analyzing Tone and Attitude
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Analyzing Tone and Attitude

More questions from this topic