Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumAnalyzing Divergent Ideas and Disagreement

Passage A

Congestion pricing—charging drivers a fee to enter busy city centers during peak hours—is the most elegant market-based solution to urban traffic gridlock. By placing a direct price on the scarce resource of road space, it encourages commuters to carpool, travel during off-peak times, or use public transportation. The success of Stockholm's congestion zone shows that when drivers face the real societal cost of their travel choices, gridlock decreases by over twenty percent, and carbon emissions drop. Crucially, the revenue generated can be reinvested into expanding public bus and rail networks. The primary obstacle to implementing this policy is not its efficacy, but rather the initial public reluctance to pay for what was previously perceived as free.

Passage B

While proponents of congestion pricing tout its environmental benefits, they overlook the stark socioeconomic inequities the policy reinforces. Decades of gentrification have pushed low-income service workers out of urban cores and into outer suburbs, where public transit infrastructure is sparse or non-existent. For these commuters, driving is not a luxury, but a necessity to reach their workplaces. A flat toll on entering the city center acts as a regressive tax, consuming a much larger share of a low-income driver's earnings than a wealthy commuter's. Imposing these fees before affordable, reliable transit alternatives are established in peripheral neighborhoods unfairly penalizes vulnerable populations under the guise of ecological progress.

Based on the passages, the authors of the two passages disagree most strongly on which of the following issues regarding congestion pricing?

  1. A
    Whether congestion pricing is effective at reducing urban traffic gridlock and environmental emissions
  2. B
    Whether public reluctance to pay road fees is the primary obstacle to the success of congestion pricing
  3. Whether congestion pricing should be implemented before reliable public transit alternatives are established in outlying areasAnswer
  4. D
    Whether the revenue generated from congestion fees is sufficient to fully fund public transit networks

Answer

Whether congestion pricing should be implemented before reliable public transit alternatives are established in outlying areas
The correct answer is the option stating that the authors disagree on whether congestion pricing should be implemented before reliable public transit alternatives are established in outlying areas. The author of Passage A views congestion pricing as a tool that generates revenue to expand transit networks, implying implementation comes first. The author of Passage B, however, explicitly states that imposing these fees before transit alternatives are established in peripheral neighborhoods unfairly penalizes commuters, showing a clear disagreement on the sequence of these actions.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze Passage A's stance on the timing and relationship between congestion pricing and transit funding.
Passage A suggests that congestion pricing is an elegant solution and that the revenue generated from it can be reinvested to expand transit networks, meaning the pricing is implemented first and used to improve transit.
To establish the first viewpoint on when and how congestion pricing should be integrated with transit development.
2
Analyze Passage B's stance on the timeline and relationship between congestion pricing and transit availability.
Passage B explicitly states that imposing these fees before affordable, reliable transit alternatives are established in peripheral neighborhoods unfairly penalizes vulnerable populations.
To establish the second viewpoint and contrast it with Passage A.
3
Compare the two viewpoints to find the direct point of disagreement.
Passage A supports implementation to generate transit funding, while Passage B argues that transit alternatives must exist before fees are imposed. This shows a direct disagreement over the timing of implementation relative to transit availability.
To select the option that accurately represents this point of disagreement.

Key Concept

Analyzing Divergent Ideas and Disagreement
Rate this question

Topics

Analyzing Divergent Ideas and Disagreement

More questions from this topic