Question

Difficulty: HardAnalyzing Mathematical Relations in Models

Astrophysicists model the equilibrium temperature, TeqT_{eq} (in kelvins, K\text{K}), of a planet orbiting a star using the following equation:

Teq=[L(1a)16πσd2]1/4T_{eq} = \left[ \frac{L(1 - a)}{16 \pi \sigma d^2} \right]^{1/4}

where LL is the star's luminosity, aa is the planet's albedo (the fraction of star radiation reflected by the planet), dd is the average distance from the star to the planet, and σ\sigma is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant. Based on this model, match each proposed change in the physical parameters of the system (on the left) to its resulting effect on the equilibrium temperature TeqT_{eq} (on the right).

  • The distance dd from the star is multiplied by 44 (4d4d), with LL and aa held constant.TeqT_{eq} is multiplied by 12\frac{1}{2}.
  • The star's luminosity LL is multiplied by 1616 (16L16L), with dd and aa held constant.TeqT_{eq} is multiplied by 22.
  • The distance dd is multiplied by 22 (2d2d) and the luminosity LL is multiplied by 44 (4L4L), with aa held constant.TeqT_{eq} remains unchanged.
  • The term (1a)(1 - a) is multiplied by 181\frac{1}{81}, with LL and dd held constant.TeqT_{eq} is multiplied by 13\frac{1}{3}.

Answer

Matching the parameter changes to their correct scaling factors: multiplying distance by 4 halves the temperature; multiplying luminosity by 16 doubles the temperature; multiplying distance by 2 and luminosity by 4 leaves temperature unchanged; and multiplying the albedo term by 1/81 scales temperature by 1/3.
Each relationship is correctly derived by applying the respective scaling factor to the variable and evaluating the term under the fourth root: multiplying the distance by 4 results in a factor of (42)1/4=161/4=1/2(4^2)^{-1/4} = 16^{-1/4} = 1/2; multiplying the luminosity by 16 results in a factor of (16)1/4=2(16)^{1/4} = 2; scaling both distance by 2 and luminosity by 4 scales the fraction by 4/22=14 / 2^2 = 1, leaving the temperature unchanged; and scaling the albedo term (1a)(1-a) by 1/81 yields a factor of (1/81)1/4=1/3(1/81)^{1/4} = 1/3.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Isolate the proportional relationship of each variable to TeqT_{eq} by removing constants (1616, π\pi, σ\sigma).
Teq[L(1a)d2]1/4=L1/4(1a)1/4d1/2T_{eq} \propto \left[ \frac{L(1-a)}{d^2} \right]^{1/4} = L^{1/4} (1-a)^{1/4} d^{-1/2}.
This establishes how scaling each parameter mathematically impacts the overall temperature.
2
Determine the scale factor for the first scenario where distance dd is multiplied by 4.
The distance term becomes (4)1/2=14=12(4)^{-1/2} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{4}} = \frac{1}{2}.
Because distance is squared and in the denominator under a fourth root, its scaling factor is 1/d1/\sqrt{d}.
3
Determine the scale factor for the second scenario where luminosity LL is multiplied by 16.
The luminosity term becomes (16)1/4=2(16)^{1/4} = 2.
Luminosity is directly proportional under the fourth root, so scaling it by 16 doubles the final value.
4
Determine the scale factor for the third scenario where distance dd is multiplied by 2 and luminosity LL is multiplied by 4.
The joint factor is (4)1/4×(22)1/4=41/4×41/4=1(4)^{1/4} \times (2^2)^{-1/4} = 4^{1/4} \times 4^{-1/4} = 1.
The scaling in the numerator (44) matches the scaling in the denominator (22=42^2 = 4), which cancels out completely.
5
Determine the scale factor for the fourth scenario where (1a)(1-a) is multiplied by 1/811/81.
The albedo term scaling is (181)1/4=13(\frac{1}{81})^{1/4} = \frac{1}{3}.
The term (1a)(1-a) is directly proportional under the fourth root, so scaling it by 1/811/81 reduces temperature to 1/31/3 of its value.

Key Concept

Analyzing proportional scaling and fractional power relations in a multi-variable physical model.
Rate this question