Question

Difficulty: HardFulfilling Specific Rhetorical and Writing Goals

The writer wants to arrange the following sentences to logically trace how a highly classified military surveillance technology unexpectedly became an invaluable tool for marine biologists. What is the most logical order for these sentences?

  1. 1In the early 1950s, the United States Navy deployed the Sound Surveillance System (SOSUS), a secretive network of underwater hydrophones designed to detect Soviet submarines.
  2. 2Operating in the deep ocean's sound channel, these sensitive listening posts immediately began picking up strange, low-frequency hums that military analysts could not identify.
  3. 3For decades, these recordings remained classified, but in the late 1980s, the Navy finally permitted select marine scientists access to the underwater audio data.
  4. 4Biologists quickly recognized these mystery signals as the long-distance communication of blue and fin whales, transforming a Cold War espionage tool into a window for ecological research.

Answer

The most logical order is to start with the introduction of SOSUS, followed by the detection of mysterious sounds, then the transition when scientists were granted access to the classified recordings, and finally the discovery that the signals were whale songs.
The correct order follows a clear chronological and logical progression. First, the Sound Surveillance System (SOSUS) is introduced along with its military purpose. Second, the text explains that these underwater hydrophones ('these sensitive listening posts') picked up mysterious hums. Third, it recounts that these audio files ('these recordings') were classified until the late 1980s when scientists were given access. Finally, it describes the outcome of that access: biologists identifying the signals as whale songs, which fulfills the rhetorical goal.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the introductory sentence.
The sentence introducing the Sound Surveillance System (SOSUS) in the 1950s serves as the logical starting point, as it provides the necessary context and defines the technology without relying on preceding information.
An introductory sentence must establish the topic independently.
2
Link the second sentence using pronoun/demonstrative references.
The sentence beginning with 'these sensitive listening posts' must follow the introduction because 'listening posts' refers back to the 'underwater hydrophones' in the introduction.
Cohesive markers like 'these' require an antecedent in the previous sentence.
3
Connect the next chronological development.
The sentence noting that 'these recordings' remained classified before being shared in the 1980s follows, as 'these recordings' refers to the 'strange, low-frequency hums' picked up by the listening posts.
This establishes the transition of the data from military classification to civilian scientific access.
4
Determine the concluding resolution.
The sentence explaining that biologists recognized 'these mystery signals' as whale songs resolves the narrative by showing the outcome of scientific access.
This completes the rhetorical goal of explaining how submarine surveillance tech became a tool for marine biology.

Key Concept

Logical sentence sequencing using reference words (pronouns, demonstratives) and narrative structure to achieve specific rhetorical goals.
Rate this question