Question

Difficulty: HardCause-and-Effect Relationships

Thomas Newcomen's atmospheric steam engine, introduced in 1712, was a major step in industrial history. Read the following passage and answer the question:

In the early eighteenth century, British coal mining hit a geological ceiling. As miners excavated deeper shafts to meet the growing demand for fuel, they frequently breached deep-seated aquifers, flooding the mines and halting production. The existing method of draining these shafts—using teams of horses to haul buckets of water to the surface—was prohibitively expensive and inefficient at greater depths. This operational crisis directly catalyzed Thomas Newcomen’s invention of the atmospheric steam engine in 1712. Designed specifically to power water pumps, Newcomen's engine successfully drained the flooded shafts, allowing miners to reach previously inaccessible coal seams. However, because these early engines were highly inefficient, they consumed a significant portion of the coal they helped extract. This high fuel consumption restricted their initial deployment almost exclusively to the pitheads of coal mines, where fuel was virtually free. Consequently, rather than immediately transforming general manufacturing, the early steam engine’s primary effect was to drastically increase the domestic supply of coal, which in turn lowered fuel costs for other industries and eventually paved the way for wider industrialization.

According to the passage, the high fuel consumption of early Newcomen steam engines had which of the following effects?

  1. It confined the engines' operation to the immediate vicinity of coal mines, postponing their integration into broader manufacturing sectors.Answer
  2. B
    It arose because the engines were immediately implemented across diverse manufacturing industries that lacked cheap coal.
  3. C
    It compelled mine operators to rely on expensive teams of horses to drain water from the deepest mine shafts.
  4. D
    It caused miners to breach deep-seated aquifers and halt production as they dug deeper shafts.

Answer

The high fuel consumption of the early Newcomen steam engines confined their operation to the immediate vicinity of coal mines, postponing their integration into broader manufacturing sectors.
The correct answer accurately reflects the passage's explanation that the high fuel consumption of the early steam engines restricted their deployment to coal mines (where fuel was free), which in turn delayed their adoption in general manufacturing.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the portion of the text that discusses the high fuel consumption of early Newcomen steam engines.
The text states: 'However, because these early engines were highly inefficient, they consumed a significant portion of the coal they helped extract. This high fuel consumption restricted their initial deployment almost exclusively to the pitheads of coal mines...'
This establishes the direct cause (high fuel consumption) and its immediate effect (restricted initial deployment to coal mine pitheads).
2
Identify the broader consequence of this restricted deployment.
The text states: 'Consequently, rather than immediately transforming general manufacturing, the early steam engine’s primary effect was to drastically increase the domestic supply of coal...'
This shows the downstream effect: the restriction to pitheads prevented the engine from immediately transforming general manufacturing, delaying its adoption in other sectors.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one that accurately paraphrases this causal relationship and eliminate the distractors.
The option stating that the engine's operation was confined to coal mines, postponing integration into broader manufacturing, is correct. The other options either reverse the cause-and-effect relationship or describe events that occurred prior to or independently of the engine's fuel usage.
This confirms the correct choice based on direct textual evidence while avoiding common misinterpretations.

Key Concept

Identifying implicit or explicit cause-and-effect relationships within a passage and tracking their logical progression.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question