Question

Difficulty: HardParagraph Reordering and Placement

[1] In 1799, during Napoleon’s Egyptian campaign, French soldiers uncovered a slab of black granodiorite near the town of Rashid (Rosetta). This artifact, carved in 196 BCE, featured a royal decree written in three distinct scripts: Ancient Greek, Demotic, and hieroglyphs. Because the Greek text was easily read, scholars immediately realized that the stone could serve as a translation key, yet deciphering the complex Egyptian hieroglyphic script would prove to be a monumental challenge that spanned decades.

[2] Today, the Rosetta Stone remains one of the British Museum's most famous acquisitions, symbolizing the triumph of historical linguistics. Visitors from around the world gather to view the artifact, reflecting on how a single stone bridged the gap between an ancient civilization and the modern world.

[3] Early progress was made by the English polymath Thomas Young, who focused on the cartouches—oval loops enclosing groups of hieroglyphs. Young correctly hypothesized that these symbols spelled out the names of royalty, such as Ptolemy, phonetically rather than representing abstract concepts. However, Young's work stalled because he believed that phonetic hieroglyphs were only used for foreign names, leaving the rest of the script a mystery.

[4] Building upon these initial insights, French linguist Jean-François Champollion dedicated himself to cracking the remaining code. By comparing the Rosetta Stone’s inscriptions with another bilingual obelisk from Philae, Champollion realized that hieroglyphs were not merely symbolic or purely phonetic, but a sophisticated combination of both. In 1822, he famously rushed into his brother’s office, shouted "Je tiens mon affaire!" ("I've got it!"), and collapsed from exhaustion.

To make the essay's structure most logical, Paragraph 2 should be placed:

  1. A
    in its current position
  2. B
    prior to Paragraph 1
  3. C
    following Paragraph 3
  4. following Paragraph 4Answer

Answer

following Paragraph 4
The correct answer is the option that places the paragraph following Paragraph 4. The essay is structured chronologically, moving from the stone's discovery in 1799 (Paragraph 1) to the early decipherment efforts of Thomas Young (Paragraph 3), then to Champollion's subsequent breakthrough in 1822 (Paragraph 4), and finally to the stone's modern status (Paragraph 2). Furthermore, placing Paragraph 2 in its current position interrupts the logical link between Paragraph 1 (which introduces the translation challenge) and Paragraph 3 (which begins describing the progress made on that challenge). Placing Paragraph 2 at the end of the essay, following Paragraph 4, ensures a smooth chronological progression and keeps the developmental steps of deciphering the hieroglyphs connected.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the chronological markers and logical flow of the historical narrative throughout the passage.
Paragraph 1 introduces the stone's discovery in 1799 and the decade-long challenge of decipherment. Paragraph 3 details the early progress by Thomas Young. Paragraph 4 details the breakthrough in 1822. Paragraph 2 describes the modern status ('Today') of the stone in a museum.
Identifying the sequence of events is crucial for ordering a chronological passage.
2
Examine the transition between Paragraph 3 and Paragraph 4 to check for cohesive links.
Paragraph 4 begins with 'Building upon these initial insights,' which refers back to Thomas Young's hypotheses about cartouches in Paragraph 3.
Pronouns and referential phrases like 'these initial insights' require the source paragraph to immediately precede them to avoid breaking cohesion.
3
Determine the correct position of Paragraph 2 based on its temporal marker.
Since Paragraph 2 begins with 'Today' and discusses the modern legacy of the stone, it logically functions as the conclusion of the essay, following the historical narrative which ends with the 1822 breakthrough in Paragraph 4.
Placing the modern conclusion at the end preserves the overall chronological structure and prevents it from interrupting the past-tense historical narrative.

Key Concept

Paragraph Reordering and Placement
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question