Question

Difficulty: MediumTranslating Data Formats

Oceanographers measured the sound velocity in seawater at various depths under two different salinity levels (34 ppt34\text{ ppt} and 36 ppt36\text{ ppt}). The results are recorded in Table 1 below:

Depth (m)Sound Velocity at 34 ppt (m/s)Sound Velocity at 36 ppt (m/s)
01,5201,523
2001,4951,498
6001,4751,478
1,0001,4701,473
1,5001,4801,483
2,0001,4901,493

Statement: If the data in Table 1 were translated into a two-line graph plotting Sound Velocity (m/s) on the y-axis against Depth (m) on the x-axis, both curves would reach a minimum value at a depth of 1,000 m1,000\text{ m}, and the curve representing 36 ppt36\text{ ppt} salinity would be positioned strictly above the curve representing 34 ppt34\text{ ppt} salinity across all measured depths.

Answer: Answer

Answer

The statement is True.
The statement accurately reflects the conversion of the tabular data into a line graph. In Table 1, both sound velocity columns drop to their lowest values (1,470 m/s1,470\text{ m/s} and 1,473 m/s1,473\text{ m/s}) at a depth of 1,000 m1,000\text{ m} before rising again, creating a V-shaped curve minimum at x=1,000 mx = 1,000\text{ m}. Additionally, at every listed depth, the value for 36 ppt36\text{ ppt} is higher than for 34 ppt34\text{ ppt}, placing the 36 ppt36\text{ ppt} curve vertically above the 34 ppt34\text{ ppt} curve.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the trend along the vertical axis variable (Sound Velocity) as a function of the horizontal axis variable (Depth) for both datasets.
For 34 ppt34\text{ ppt}, velocities are 1,5201,4951,4751,4701,4801,4901,520 \rightarrow 1,495 \rightarrow 1,475 \rightarrow 1,470 \rightarrow 1,480 \rightarrow 1,490. The lowest point (minimum) occurs at 1,000 m1,000\text{ m} (1,470 m/s1,470\text{ m/s}). For 36 ppt36\text{ ppt}, velocities are 1,5231,4981,4781,4731,4831,4931,523 \rightarrow 1,498 \rightarrow 1,478 \rightarrow 1,473 \rightarrow 1,483 \rightarrow 1,493. The lowest point also occurs at 1,000 m1,000\text{ m} (1,473 m/s1,473\text{ m/s}).
Determining where the graph reaches its lowest point requires identifying the minimum y-value for each x-value series.
2
Compare the relative vertical height (y-values) of the two salinity series across all depth levels (x-values).
At depth 0 m0\text{ m}: 1,523>1,5201,523 > 1,520; at 200 m200\text{ m}: 1,498>1,4951,498 > 1,495; at 600 m600\text{ m}: 1,478>1,4751,478 > 1,475; at 1,000 m1,000\text{ m}: 1,473>1,4701,473 > 1,470; at 1,500 m1,500\text{ m}: 1,483>1,4801,483 > 1,480; at 2,000 m2,000\text{ m}: 1,493>1,4901,493 > 1,490.
A curve with higher y-values at every x-value will be graphed higher up (above) another curve.
3
Synthesize the graphical behavior described in the statement with the tabular evidence.
Both curves reach a minimum at 1,000 m1,000\text{ m} and the 36 ppt36\text{ ppt} line remains strictly higher on the y-axis than the 34 ppt34\text{ ppt} line at all points. Thus, the statement is true.
The textual description of the proposed graph matches the tabular data perfectly in both shape (minimum location) and relative alignment.

Key Concept

Translating tabular data to graphical trends by matching values to axes, extrema, and relative curve placements.
Rate this question