Question

Difficulty: MediumIdentifying Narrator Point of View

For thirty years, Mr. Gellar had operated the antique shop on Elm Street as if it were a private museum rather than a retail business. To him, every cracked porcelain teacup and tarnished brass pocket watch possessed a living history that could not simply be bartered away to the highest bidder. I often sat on the faded velvet stool near the counter, watching him politely discourage customers whose appreciation for his treasures seemed superficial. 'No, no,' he would murmur, gently extracting a dust-covered volume of poetry from a tourist’s hands, 'that one is not quite ready to leave.'

My role was that of a quiet observer, a chronicler of his quiet eccentricities. While the townspeople regarded him as a stubborn hermit who stood in the way of his own financial success, I saw a dedicated guardian of history. I wondered if he realized that his refusal to participate in the modern rush of commerce was itself a form of art. When developers eventually bought the block to make way for a modern shopping complex, Mr. Gellar did not protest or join the public town hall debates; he simply locked the door, leaving his inventory exactly as it was, a silent monument to a bygone era that the rest of the world was too busy to remember. As I watched the dust settle on the windows from across the street, I realized that the shop's closure was not a defeat for Mr. Gellar, but rather the final, deliberate chapter of his collection.

Which of the following best describes the narrator's perspective and relationship to the events described in the passage?

  1. A first-person observer who respects Mr. Gellar's eccentricities and appreciates his dedication to preserving the past.Answer
  2. B
    An activist author writing a social critique to expose the negative economic impact of urban development on small business owners.
  3. C
    A third-person limited narrator focusing on Mr. Gellar's internal anxieties and financial struggles to maintain his business.
  4. D
    A first-person business partner who actively assists Mr. Gellar in running the shop and shares his resentment toward the developers.

Answer

A first-person observer who respects Mr. Gellar's eccentricities and appreciates his dedication to preserving the past.
The narrator uses first-person pronouns and describes their role as a 'quiet observer' who watches Mr. Gellar. The narrator's tone is respectful and appreciative, calling Mr. Gellar a 'dedicated guardian of history' and characterizing his actions as 'a form of art' rather than financial failure.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate narrative voice indicators and personal pronouns in the text.
The text uses 'I' and 'my' (e.g., 'I often sat', 'My role was that of a quiet observer'), which establishes a first-person point of view.
Determining first-person versus third-person pronouns is the first step in identifying point of view.
2
Determine the narrator's level of participation and role in the story.
The narrator states, 'My role was that of a quiet observer, a chronicler of his quiet eccentricities,' indicating they watch rather than run the shop or shape the events.
This distinguishes a first-person protagonist from a first-person observer narrator.
3
Evaluate the narrator's attitude toward the subject matter.
The narrator views Mr. Gellar positively, describing him as a 'dedicated guardian of history' and his actions as 'itself a form of art.'
This clarifies the narrator's perspective and relationship to Mr. Gellar, pointing to the correct choice.

Key Concept

Identifying Narrator Point of View
Rate this question