Question

Difficulty: MediumComparing and Contrasting Models

### Models of the Permian-Triassic Extinction Event

The Permian-Triassic (P-Tr) extinction event, which occurred approximately 252 million years ago252\text{ million years ago}, resulted in the loss of over 90%90\% of marine species. Geologists have proposed different models to explain the cause of this mass extinction.

Model 1 (Volcanic Outgassing Model)
This model proposes that the eruption of the Siberian Traps, a massive region of volcanic rock, released enormous volumes of carbon dioxide (CO2CO_2) and methane (CH4CH_4) into the atmosphere over a span of several hundred thousand years. This led to rapid global warming of approximately 10C10^\circ\text{C}, causing severe ocean acidification. Warm oceans absorbed less oxygen, leading to widespread ocean anoxia (oxygen depletion), which suffocated marine life.

Model 2 (Bolide Impact Model)
This model proposes that a large asteroid or comet (bolide) collided with Earth at the P-Tr boundary. The impact vaporized target rocks containing anhydrite (CaSO4CaSO_4), releasing massive quantities of sulfur dioxide (SO2SO_2) into the stratosphere. This caused global cooling and severe acid rain. The subsequent collapse of land and ocean food webs led to massive organic decay, which depleted dissolved oxygen in the oceans, causing widespread marine anoxia.

Instruction:
Based on the models provided, match each description of an extinction trigger, mechanism, or timeline on the left with the model(s) on the right that it describes.

  • The mass extinction event was initiated by massive terrestrial volcanic eruptions.Model 1 only
  • The mass extinction event was initiated by an extraterrestrial collision.Model 2 only
  • Widespread marine oxygen depletion (anoxia) served as a direct mechanism for species loss.Both Model 1 and Model 2
  • The mass extinction event occurred gradually over 50 million years50\text{ million years} due to continental drift.Neither Model 1 nor Model 2

Answer

The mass extinction event initiated by massive terrestrial volcanic eruptions matches Model 1 only. The mass extinction event initiated by an extraterrestrial collision matches Model 2 only. Widespread marine oxygen depletion (anoxia) serving as a direct mechanism for species loss matches Both Model 1 and Model 2. The mass extinction event occurring gradually over 50 million years due to continental drift matches Neither Model 1 nor Model 2.
Matching the extinction triggers and mechanisms directly to the models: Volcanic eruptions are unique to the Volcanic Outgassing Model (Model 1); a bolide collision is unique to the Bolide Impact Model (Model 2); ocean oxygen depletion (anoxia) is a shared consequence of both models; continental drift is not proposed by either model.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze Model 1 and Model 2 for the proposed initiation mechanism of the extinction.
Model 1 attributes the start to Siberian Traps volcanism (terrestrial volcanic eruptions), matching the first description. Model 2 attributes the start to an asteroid or comet impact (extraterrestrial collision), matching the second description.
To distinguish the unique triggers proposed by each model.
2
Analyze both models for shared consequences or mechanisms of marine extinction.
Model 1 states that warm oceans led to widespread ocean anoxia, and Model 2 states that massive organic decay depleted dissolved oxygen, leading to marine anoxia. Thus, both models agree that ocean anoxia was a direct cause, matching the third description.
To identify points of agreement or common final pathways between the models.
3
Evaluate the remaining description regarding continental drift and a 50 million year50\text{ million year} timeline.
Model 1 describes a span of several hundred thousand years and volcanic outgassing. Model 2 describes an impact and subsequent rapid food web collapse. Neither model mentions continental drift or a 50 million year50\text{ million year} timescale, matching the fourth description to 'Neither Model 1 nor Model 2'.
To check if any of the statements describe factors external to both models.

Key Concept

Comparing and Contrasting Models
Rate this question