Question

Difficulty: EasyComparing and Contrasting Models

How and when the Grand Canyon was formed is a subject of debate among geologists. Two models propose different timelines and mechanisms for its creation:

Model 1 (Ancient Canyon Hypothesis)
This model proposes that the carving of the Grand Canyon began approximately 70 million70\text{ million} years ago (70 Ma70\text{ Ma}). Ancestral river systems slowly carved the canyon over tens of millions of years, driven by the gradual tectonic uplift of the Colorado Plateau. According to this model, the modern Colorado River simply adopted this pre-existing, ancient canyon system.

Model 2 (Young Canyon Hypothesis)
This model proposes that the Grand Canyon is a relatively recent feature, with carving beginning only about 6 million6\text{ million} years ago (6 Ma6\text{ Ma}). In this view, several smaller, separate paleocanyons were cut by different rivers over time, but these did not become the Grand Canyon until the modern Colorado River carved through the barriers separating them, integrating the system rapidly within the last 6 million6\text{ million} years.

Based on Model 1 and Model 2, the two models differ on which of the following aspects of the Grand Canyon?

  1. The approximate time at which the carving of the canyon system beganAnswer
  2. B
    The primary agent of erosion responsible for carving the canyon
  3. C
    The role of the Colorado River system in the canyon's history
  4. D
    The geologic composition of the canyon rock layers

Answer

The approximate time at which the carving of the canyon system began
The two models differ on the timeline of the canyon's creation. Model 1 states that the carving began approximately 70 million70\text{ million} years ago, while Model 2 states it began about 6 million6\text{ million} years ago.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the timeline proposed by Model 1.
Model 1 asserts that carving began approximately 70 million70\text{ million} years ago.
This establishes the start time of canyon carving according to the Ancient Canyon Hypothesis.
2
Identify the timeline proposed by Model 2.
Model 2 asserts that carving began about 6 million6\text{ million} years ago.
This establishes the start time of canyon carving according to the Young Canyon Hypothesis.
3
Compare the two timelines to determine the point of disagreement.
The two models disagree on when the carving process began (70 million70\text{ million} years ago versus 6 million6\text{ million} years ago).
This comparison directly answers the question about how the two models differ.

Key Concept

Comparing and Contrasting Models
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question