Question

Difficulty: Very hardParagraph Reordering and Placement

The following paragraphs are from an essay about a major discovery in marine biology.

[1]
In 1977, a team of oceanographers aboard the research submersible *Alvin* descended into the Pacific Ocean near the Galápagos Islands. They expected to find a barren, freezing desert at the ocean floor, where sunlight could not reach. Instead, they discovered a bustling ecosystem of giant tube worms, blind crabs, and vast fields of clams thriving in the pitch-black waters.

[2]
To sustain this vibrant community without sunlight, a process entirely different from photosynthesis had to be occurring. Geochemists quickly identified that specialized bacteria were oxidizing toxic hydrogen sulfide spewing from the hydrothermal vents, converting the chemical energy into organic matter. This ground-breaking discovery of chemosynthesis challenged the long-held biological dogma that all life ultimately relies on solar energy.

[3]
Prior to this expedition, marine biologists had assumed that the deep ocean depended solely on a sparse "rain" of organic debris drifting down from the sunlit surface. The discovery of hydrothermal vents completely upended this model, proving that planetary heat could also fuel complex life.

[4]
Consequently, these hydrothermal vent communities became a primary model for studying how life might arise on other worlds, such as Jupiter's icy moon Europa. Before scientists could speculate about extraterrestrial life, however, they had to understand how this ecosystem survived in such extreme conditions.

For the sake of the logic and cohesion of this essay, where is the most appropriate place to position Paragraph 2?

  1. A
    where it is now
  2. B
    before Paragraph 1
  3. C
    after Paragraph 3
  4. after Paragraph 4Answer

Answer

after Paragraph 4
The correct choice is to place Paragraph 2 after Paragraph 4. Paragraph 4 ends with the observation that scientists needed to understand how the hydrothermal vent ecosystem survived in extreme conditions. Placing Paragraph 2 immediately after Paragraph 4 creates a logical sequence, as Paragraph 2 explains the process of chemosynthesis that allowed the community to survive. Furthermore, this ordering places Paragraph 3 immediately after Paragraph 1, which works well because Paragraph 3's reference to 'this expedition' points directly back to the 1977 expedition introduced in Paragraph 1.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the connection between Paragraph 1 and the other paragraphs to determine chronology.
Paragraph 1 introduces the 1977 expedition and the discovery of a deep-sea ecosystem. Paragraph 3 begins with 'Prior to this expedition,' which directly refers to the 1977 expedition in Paragraph 1. Therefore, Paragraph 3 must follow Paragraph 1.
To establish a clear chronological and thematic link between the expedition and the scientific assumptions that preceded it.
2
Determine the placement of Paragraph 4 relative to Paragraph 3.
Paragraph 3 concludes by stating that the discovery proved planetary heat could fuel complex life. Paragraph 4 begins with 'Consequently,' which draws a logical conclusion from this proof by explaining that these communities became models for studying extraterrestrial life on worlds like Europa. Thus, Paragraph 4 must follow Paragraph 3.
To maintain a logical cause-and-effect transition between the discovery's implications on Earth and its application to space exploration.
3
Determine the placement of Paragraph 2 based on cohesion clues.
Paragraph 4 concludes with the statement that scientists 'had to understand how this ecosystem survived.' Paragraph 2 directly answers this query by explaining the process of chemosynthesis that sustains the community. Therefore, Paragraph 2 must be placed after Paragraph 4.
To ensure that the explanation of the survival mechanism immediately follows the statement of the need to understand it.

Key Concept

Determining the logical order of paragraphs in an essay using transitional phrases, chronological markers, and pronoun references.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question