Question

Difficulty: MediumFulfilling Specific Rhetorical and Writing Goals

When Mount Vesuvius erupted in 79 CE, it buried the Roman town of Herculaneum under a thick layer of volcanic ash. Villa excavations in the mid-eighteenth century revealed a library filled with hundreds of carbonized papyrus scrolls. For centuries, attempts to unroll these fragile documents resulted in their disintegration. Recently, however, researchers have utilized non-invasive imaging techniques to read the scrolls without physically touching them.

Using high-energy X-ray phase-contrast tomography, scientists can map the minute differences in thickness and texture of the carbonized ink compared to the carbonized paper. ____________ By translating these digital scans into three-dimensional models, researchers are beginning to read words that have been locked away for nearly two millennia.

The writer wants to add a sentence at the underlined portion to highlight the physical similarity between the ink and the scrolls, illustrating why traditional imaging methods fail. Which choice most effectively accomplishes this goal?

  1. A
    Since the ink was carbon-based and chemically identical to the charred papyrus; traditional X-rays could not distinguish the writing.
  2. B
    The ink was carbon-based, it was chemically identical to the charred papyrus, this made it impossible for traditional X-rays to distinguish the text.
  3. Because the ink was carbon-based—chemically identical to the charred papyrus itself—traditional X-rays could not distinguish between the writing and the background.Answer
  4. D
    Although the scrolls were housed in a magnificent villa that once belonged to Julius Caesar's father-in-law, they are now kept in Naples.

Answer

Because the ink was carbon-based—chemically identical to the charred papyrus itself—traditional X-rays could not distinguish between the writing and the background.
The correct answer is the option starting with 'Because the ink was carbon-based'. It is grammatically correct and successfully fulfills the rhetorical goal by detailing the chemical composition (carbon-based, identical to the papyrus) and explaining why this made traditional X-ray imaging ineffective.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the prompt to identify the specific rhetorical goal.
The goal is to select an option that emphasizes the physical similarity between the ink and the scroll material, explaining why traditional X-ray methods failed.
Identifying the target criteria helps eliminate choices that focus on irrelevant details.
2
Evaluate the choices for grammatical correctness.
The option beginning with 'Since the ink was' contains a semicolon punctuation error. The option beginning with 'The ink was carbon-based' contains a comma splice. The option beginning with 'Because the ink was' and the option beginning with 'Although the scrolls' are both grammatically correct.
ACT questions require grammatically correct sentences, so grammatically incorrect distractors can be eliminated immediately.
3
Evaluate the remaining grammatically correct choices against the rhetorical goal.
The option beginning with 'Although the scrolls' discusses the historical villa, which is irrelevant to the goal. The option beginning with 'Because the ink was' directly explains the chemical similarity (both are carbon-based) and links this to the failure of traditional X-rays.
This identifies the only choice that is both grammatically correct and fully aligns with the specified rhetorical goal.

Key Concept

Fulfilling Specific Rhetorical and Writing Goals
Estimated Time:1m 15s
Rate this question