Question

Difficulty: HardEvaluating Supporting Evidence

For decades, biologists hypothesized that juvenile play behavior in mammals serves primarily to refine the motor skills needed for adulthood, such as hunting or escaping predators. However, evolutionary biologist Dr. Evelyn Vance argues that play's primary function is cognitive adaptability. Vance points out that play is characterized by highly exaggerated, non-functional sequences that do not replicate actual hunting or flight behaviors. Furthermore, her observations of juvenile brown bears revealed that individuals engaging in high levels of play did not exhibit superior hunting success rates as adults compared to their less playful peers. Instead, Vance's research showed that bears subjected to unpredictable, play-deprived environments struggled significantly to adapt to novel environmental stressors, such as sudden shifts in food availability or territory intrusion. To support her cognitive flexibility model, Vance cites neurological studies showing that play stimulates the growth of neural connections in the prefrontal cortex, the brain region responsible for decision-making and behavioral flexibility. Therefore, Vance concludes that play functions as a safe laboratory where juveniles experience a temporary loss of control to prepare their brains for unexpected future challenges.

According to the passage, which of the following findings does Dr. Vance present as direct evidence to support her conclusion that play prepares animals for unexpected environmental challenges?

  1. A
    The observation that juvenile brown bears who engaged in high levels of play achieved significantly higher hunting success rates as adults.
  2. B
    The assertion that play serves as a safe behavioral laboratory where juveniles can experience a temporary loss of control.
  3. The finding that juvenile bears raised in play-deprived environments struggled to adapt to sudden changes in food availability or territory.Answer
  4. D
    The finding that play-deprived environments stimulate the growth of neural connections responsible for motor memory.

Answer

The finding that juvenile bears raised in play-deprived environments struggled to adapt to sudden changes in food availability or territory.
The correct answer is correct because it accurately summarizes the empirical findings Dr. Vance uses to support her conclusion. The passage explicitly links the struggles of play-deprived bears in adapting to sudden shifts in food and territory with the idea that play prepares animals for unexpected future challenges.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the claim in question.
The target claim is Dr. Vance's conclusion that play prepares animals for unexpected environmental challenges.
Understanding what claim we need to find support for focuses the search on the relevant parts of the passage.
2
Locate the evidence presented in the text for this claim.
The passage states that bears subjected to play-deprived environments struggled to adapt to novel environmental stressors, such as sudden shifts in food availability or territory intrusion.
This direct link between play deprivation and an inability to handle unexpected changes provides the empirical basis for Vance's conclusion.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one that matches this evidence without introducing distortions.
The option describing play-deprived bears struggling to adapt to food and territory shifts matches the passage's findings directly, while other options either distort the details, state the opposite, or present the claim itself rather than the supporting evidence.
Evaluating each option ensures that distractors containing minor details or misstatements are eliminated.

Key Concept

Evaluating Supporting Evidence
Rate this question