Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardRhetorical Functions of Sentences and Paragraphs

For decades, Chomskyan generative grammarians asserted that human language is governed by an innate, universal grammar hardwired into the neural circuitry of the brain. According to this paradigm, children acquire language too rapidly and from too impoverished an environment to rely solely on general-purpose cognitive learning. However, cognitive linguists have recently challenged this consensus by utilizing computational models to demonstrate that statistical learning mechanisms can extract complex syntactic patterns from everyday speech. To these researchers, the structure of language emerges organically from communicative interaction, rather than from a pre-existing genetic blueprint. Ultimately, this debate is not merely a technical dispute over syntax, but a fundamental disagreement about the very nature of human cognition.

Based on the passage, which of the following best describes the primary rhetorical function of the final sentence ('Ultimately, this debate...')?

  1. A
    It summarizes the literal scientific consensus regarding the neural circuitry involved in syntax acquisition.
  2. B
    It introduces empirical evidence to resolve the disagreement between the two competing schools of linguistics.
  3. It elevates the significance of the conflict by framing a specific academic dispute as a fundamental question about human intelligence.Answer
  4. D
    It signals a transition to a new topic by introducing a counterargument against the cognitive linguists' theories.

Answer

The option stating that the sentence elevates the significance of the conflict by framing a specific academic dispute as a fundamental question about human intelligence.
The correct option is correct because the final sentence shifts the discussion from the specific linguistic debate (syntax and universal grammar) to the broader, more significant question of how human cognition is structured.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the final sentence of the passage and read it in the context of the entire paragraph.
The final sentence states: 'Ultimately, this debate is not merely a technical dispute over syntax, but a fundamental disagreement about the very nature of human cognition.'
To identify the target sentence and analyze its immediate textual context.
2
Determine the function of the transition word 'Ultimately' and the contrast set up by 'not merely... but...'
The author uses 'Ultimately' to signal a conclusion or final synthesis, and the contrast 'not merely a technical dispute... but a fundamental disagreement' to show that the debate has wider implications than it might seem.
To analyze the structural and stylistic devices used in the sentence to convey its purpose.
3
Evaluate the relationship between the sentence and the rest of the passage.
The paragraph describes a conflict between two linguistics theories (generative grammar and cognitive linguistics). The final sentence shows that this conflict is not just about grammatical rules (syntax) but about how the human mind works (cognition).
To link the sentence's local function to the paragraph's overall argument.
4
Compare the findings with the given choices to select the one that correctly identifies this functional role.
The choice stating that it elevates the significance of the conflict by framing a specific academic dispute as a fundamental question about human intelligence matches this analysis.
To identify the correct response and eliminate options that mischaracterize the rhetorical function.

Key Concept

Identifying the rhetorical function of a sentence within a passage
Rate this question

Topics

Rhetorical Functions of Sentences and Paragraphs

More questions from this topic