Question

Difficulty: MediumDetermining Paragraph-Level Main Ideas

The following passage is adapted from an essay on the history of cartography.

[Paragraph 1] (lines 1–8)
During the Middle Ages, European cartography was dominated by the *mappa mundi*, a genre of map that served a primarily theological rather than navigational purpose. Rather than depicting literal geographic distances, these maps represented a spiritual worldview, placing Jerusalem at the center of the cosmos and organizing the known world into symbolic zones. Physical accuracy was sacrificed to convey moral and religious narratives, rendering them useless for actual travel but highly effective as educational tools for Christian cosmology.

[Paragraph 2] (lines 9–16)
In the late thirteenth century, a dramatic shift occurred with the emergence of the Portolan chart, a highly practical map designed specifically for mariners navigating the Mediterranean and Black Seas. Characterized by a network of intersecting rhumb lines—which showed wind directions—and highly detailed, realistic coastlines, Portolan charts stripped away theological allegories in favor of empirical observation. These charts enabled sailors to calculate bearings between ports directly, transforming seafaring from a risky coastal endeavor into a more predictable science.

[Paragraph 3] (lines 17–23)
This cartographic transition did not merely represent a technological upgrade; it reflected a broader intellectual evolution toward empirical inquiry that predated the Scientific Revolution. By prioritizing measured experience over ecclesiastical authority, the creators of Portolan charts established a precedent for systematic data collection. Consequently, the map ceased to be a static canvas of religious doctrine and instead became a dynamic, corrective tool that evolved alongside human exploration.

Based on the passage, which main idea best corresponds to each of the designated paragraphs?

  • Paragraph 1 (lines 1–8)The theological and symbolic function of medieval *mappae mundi* over geographic utility.
  • Paragraph 2 (lines 9–16)The development of Portolan charts as empirical, navigation-focused tools for mariners.
  • Paragraph 3 (lines 17–23)The broader shift toward empirical reasoning and scientific inquiry symbolized by the change in mapmaking.

Answer

Paragraph 1 matches the theological and symbolic function of medieval maps; Paragraph 2 matches the development of Portolan charts as practical navigational tools; Paragraph 3 matches the broader shift toward empirical reasoning and scientific inquiry.
Paragraph 1 is correctly matched to the theological and symbolic function of medieval maps because it details the religious worldviews expressed in the *mappa mundi* and notes its lack of practical travel utility. Paragraph 2 is correctly matched to the development of Portolan charts as navigational tools because it outlines their practical purpose and features for mariners. Paragraph 3 is correctly matched to the broader intellectual shift toward empirical reasoning because it explains how this cartographic change reflected a wider evolution toward scientific observation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the first paragraph for its central focus.
The first paragraph describes the *mappa mundi*, emphasizing that physical accuracy was sacrificed for moral, religious, and spiritual symbolism.
This establishes that Paragraph 1 is primarily about the theological and symbolic functions of medieval maps rather than their practical geographic utility.
2
Analyze the second paragraph for its central focus.
The second paragraph introduces Portolan charts, highlighting their design (rhumb lines, realistic coastlines) and their practical use for sailors navigating the seas.
This aligns the paragraph with the idea of Portolan charts serving as empirical, navigation-focused tools.
3
Analyze the third paragraph for its central focus.
The third paragraph argues that the shift to Portolan charts represents a broader intellectual shift toward empirical inquiry, foreshadowing the Scientific Revolution.
This matches Paragraph 3 with the broader shift toward empirical reasoning and scientific inquiry.

Key Concept

Determining Paragraph-Level Main Ideas
Estimated Time:2m 30s
Rate this question