Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardSemicolons

For centuries, the production of Tyrian purple dye was a labor-intensive process restricted to royalty; indeed, harvesting thousands of spiny dye-murex snails was required to extract just a single gram of the vibrant pigment.

Which of the following is the best replacement for the underlined portion?

  1. royalty; indeed, harvestingAnswer
  2. B
    royalty, indeed, harvesting
  3. C
    royalty; because indeed, harvesting
  4. D
    royalty; which indeed, required harvesting

Answer

The correct option is 'royalty; indeed, harvesting', which properly uses a semicolon to connect two related independent clauses.
The correct option preserves the original structure, which correctly uses a semicolon to separate two independent clauses. The conjunctive adverb 'indeed' is properly positioned after the semicolon and followed by a comma, establishing a logical connection between the difficulty of the process and the specific requirements of harvesting the snails.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the grammatical structure of the clauses flanking the punctuation.
The first clause ('For centuries, the production of Tyrian purple dye was a labor-intensive process restricted to royalty') is an independent clause. The second clause ('indeed, harvesting thousands of spiny dye-murex snails was required to extract just a single gram of the vibrant pigment') is also an independent clause.
To determine the correct punctuation, we must identify if the clauses can stand alone as complete sentences.
2
Evaluate the joining punctuation and transition words.
Since both clauses are independent, they must be separated by a period, a semicolon, or a comma paired with a coordinating conjunction. The transitional adverb 'indeed' is used here, which requires a semicolon before it and a comma after it when joining two independent clauses.
This ensures the sentence avoids comma splices and run-on structures while maintaining the logical transition.

Key Concept

Using semicolons to connect independent clauses linked by a conjunctive adverb
Rate this question

Topics

Semicolons

More questions from this topic