Question

Difficulty: MediumEvaluating Supporting Evidence

Read the following passage and match each theoretical claim regarding the self-domestication model of dogs with the specific textual excerpt from the passage that serves as its direct supporting evidence.

Passage

For decades, evolutionary biologists have debated the mechanisms underlying the transition from wild wolves to domestic dogs (Canis lupus familiaris). The traditional 'active taming' hypothesis suggests that Upper Paleolithic hunters actively captured wolf pups, hand-reared them, and selectively bred those with desirable traits. However, recent fossil evidence from archaeological sites in Siberia and Europe has challenged this view, prompting the development of the 'self-domestication' or 'commensal scavenger' model. Proponents of this theory argue that wolves initiated contact by scavenging around human hunter-gatherer camps. Wolves with shorter flight distances (less fear of humans) were more successful at accessing human food refuse. Over generations, these bolder wolves reproductively isolated themselves from wild populations, leading to anatomical and behavioral changes. While critics point out that early human waste heaps were likely insufficient to sustain a wolf subpopulation, defenders of the self-domestication model cite isotopic analyses of Paleolithic canine bones. These analyses reveal a distinct diet rich in human-provided food scraps rather than the large game typically hunted by wild wolves. Thus, rather than active human intervention, dog domestication may have begun as an evolutionary response to a new ecological niche created by human settlements.

  • The claim that wolves, rather than humans, took the initial step in the domestication process by visiting human settlements."Proponents of this theory argue that wolves initiated contact by scavenging around human hunter-gatherer camps."
  • The claim that specific behavioral traits, such as reduced fear, gave certain wolves an evolutionary advantage."Wolves with shorter flight distances (less fear of humans) were more successful at accessing human food refuse."
  • The claim that ancient canines actually consumed human food scraps rather than hunting wild game."These analyses reveal a distinct diet rich in human-provided food scraps rather than the large game typically hunted by wild wolves."

Answer

The claim about wolves initiating contact matches the excerpt describing them scavenging around camps; the claim about behavioral traits matches the excerpt about flight distances; and the claim about ancient canine diets matches the excerpt about isotopic bone analyses.
Each claim is correctly matched because the corresponding passage excerpt provides the exact details necessary to validate the assertion without requiring outside assumptions. The claim of wolf-initiated contact is verified by the sentence indicating they scavenged near camps; the claim that behavioral traits (fear reduction) offered advantages is supported by the success of wolves with shorter flight distances; and the claim about dietary composition is validated by the isotopic bone analyses showing a diet of food scraps.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the first claim regarding who initiated contact.
The text states that 'wolves initiated contact by scavenging around human hunter-gatherer camps,' directly supporting the claim that the wolves took the first step.
To connect the theoretical claim about the initiator of contact to its direct textual proof.
2
Analyze the second claim regarding the evolutionary advantage of behavioral traits.
The text explains that wolves with 'shorter flight distances' (defined in the passage as 'less fear of humans') had greater success accessing food refuse, supporting the link between behavioral traits and survival advantages.
To identify the specific behavioral trait (reduced fear) and its consequence described in the passage.
3
Analyze the third claim regarding canine diets.
The text states that 'isotopic analyses of Paleolithic canine bones' reveal a diet rich in 'human-provided food scraps' rather than large game, which directly verifies the dietary claim.
To find the empirical evidence (isotopic analysis) validating the claim about canine feeding habits.

Key Concept

Evaluating Supporting Evidence
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question