Question

Difficulty: HardDetermining Author's Primary Purpose

For decades, the dominant paradigm in paleoanthropology was the strict "Recent Out of Africa" model, which posited that anatomically modern humans emerged in Africa and subsequently migrated to displace other hominin species, such as Neanderthals, without any significant interbreeding. This replacement hypothesis painted a picture of genetic isolation, suggesting modern humans were entirely distinct from the archaic hominins they succeeded. However, the advent of paleogenomics in the early twenty-first century disrupted this consensus. By successfully sequencing the Neanderthal genome from fossilized bone fragments, researchers uncovered a startling truth: modern non-African populations share approximately one to two percent of their DNA with Neanderthals.

This genetic evidence forced a major reevaluation of human origins, giving rise to the "Leaky Replacement" or assimilation model. This framework acknowledges the primary African origin of modern humans but integrates the reality of limited interbreeding events during their dispersal across Eurasia. Critics initially argued that the shared genetic sequences might be remnants of a common ancient ancestor rather than evidence of hybridization. Yet, statistical analysis of genetic distances and the presence of longer, contiguous segments of Neanderthal DNA in early modern human fossils ultimately confirmed that interbreeding did indeed occur. Today, paleogenomists focus on identifying how these introgressed Neanderthal genes continue to influence modern human traits, ranging from immune responses to skin pigmentation, transforming our understanding of our own evolutionary tapestry from a simple branching tree into a complex, web-like network.

Based on the passage, which of the following best describes the author's primary purpose?

  1. A
    argue that early hominin species were genetically identical to modern humans.
  2. B
    detail the genetic mechanisms by which Neanderthal DNA influences modern human traits like immunity.
  3. describe how genetic evidence challenged and refined the prevailing scientific model of modern human origins.Answer
  4. D
    explain that early modern humans completely replaced Neanderthals through superior migration strategies.

Answer

describe how genetic evidence challenged and refined the prevailing scientific model of modern human origins.
The correct answer accurately summarizes the core purpose of the passage. The text is structured to show the transition from the older replacement model to the newer assimilation model, brought about by paleogenomic discoveries that confirmed interbreeding between Neanderthals and early modern humans.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the introductory section of the passage to identify the starting consensus.
The passage begins by describing the long-held "Recent Out of Africa" replacement model, which assumed genetic isolation and no interbreeding between modern humans and Neanderthals.
Establishing the starting point helps determine the direction of the author's primary argument.
2
Identify the shifting event or evidence introduced in the middle of the passage.
The passage explains that paleogenomics and the sequencing of the Neanderthal genome revealed that modern non-Africans share one to two percent of their DNA with Neanderthals.
This genetic evidence serves as the main driver of the change in scientific understanding.
3
Synthesize the resolution or current state described at the end of the passage.
The passage outlines the shift to the "Leaky Replacement" or assimilation model, which incorporates limited hybridization and alters our view of evolutionary history.
Understanding the outcome of the genetic discoveries reveals the primary purpose of the author's narrative.

Key Concept

Determining Author's Primary Purpose
Rate this question