Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumIdentifying Unstated Assumptions

Recent studies in cognitive linguistics demonstrate that native speakers of languages with grammatical gender—such as German or Spanish—frequently attribute gender-stereotyped adjectives to inanimate objects. For instance, when asked to describe a key, German speakers (for whom 'key' is masculine) often select words like 'hard' and 'heavy,' whereas Spanish speakers (for whom 'key' is feminine) prefer words like 'golden' and 'intricate.' Based on these findings, educational researchers have proposed replacing traditional foreign language instruction in primary schools with gender-neutral artificial languages. Proponents argue that eliminating grammatical gender from early language acquisition will effectively prevent children from forming subconscious gender biases regarding human professional roles. Consequently, they claim this curriculum reform is essential for building a more egalitarian society.

Which of the following represents an unstated assumption upon which the proponents' argument for curriculum reform depends?

  1. The subconscious cognitive associations formed between grammatical gender and inanimate objects transfer to how individuals perceive human social roles.Answer
  2. B
    Native speakers of languages with grammatical gender consistently attribute gender-typed traits to inanimate objects.
  3. C
    Primary school students are capable of acquiring artificial languages as rapidly as natural foreign languages.
  4. D
    Speakers of gender-neutral languages exhibit significantly lower rates of societal gender discrimination than speakers of gendered languages.

Answer

The argument relies on the unstated assumption that subconscious cognitive associations formed between grammatical gender and inanimate objects transfer to how individuals perceive human social roles.
The correct answer identifies the essential logical connection missing between the passage's evidence and its conclusion. The passage provides evidence solely regarding how grammatical gender influences descriptions of inanimate objects (keys), yet concludes that removing grammatical gender will prevent biases regarding human professional roles. For this evidence to support the conclusion, the author must assume that the mental association between linguistic gender and inanimate objects directly affects how people evaluate human social roles.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the author's primary conclusion.
The conclusion is that eliminating grammatical gender in early language instruction will prevent children from developing subconscious gender biases regarding human professional roles.
Understanding the ultimate claim is necessary to analyze what premises are required to support it.
2
Identify the explicit evidence provided in the passage.
The evidence shows that grammatical gender affects how speakers describe inanimate objects (e.g., a key).
Comparing the explicit evidence to the conclusion reveals the missing logical connection.
3
Determine the logical bridge needed between the evidence and the conclusion.
To connect evidence about inanimate objects to a conclusion about human professional roles, the author must assume that gender perceptions of inanimate objects influence perceptions of human roles.
Without this assumption, evidence about inanimate objects provides no support for claims about human social bias.

Key Concept

Identifying Unstated Assumptions in Argumentation
Rate this question

Topics

Identifying Unstated Assumptions

More questions from this topic