Question

Difficulty: MediumSupporting Claims with Evidence and Details

The following sentences are from a draft of an essay about marine biology. To ensure that the paragraph logically builds its claim that deep-sea hydrothermal vent ecosystems rely on chemosynthesis, in what order should the sentences be placed?

  1. 1Far below the ocean's photic zone, where sunlight cannot penetrate, hydrothermal vents support thriving ecosystems that depend entirely on chemosynthesis rather than photosynthesis.
  2. 2In these extreme environments, specialized bacteria oxidize toxic hydrogen sulfide spewing from the Earth's crust, converting it into organic matter.
  3. 3For example, giant tube worms (Riftia pachyptilaRiftia\ pachyptila) lack mouths and digestive tracts, relying instead on millions of these bacteria housed inside an organ called a trophosome to survive.
  4. 4Consequently, these chemosynthetic bacteria serve as the bedrock of a complex food web, supporting diverse communities of crabs, shrimp, and fish.

Answer

The correct sequence begins with the general claim about chemosynthetic ecosystems, followed by the explanation of how specialized bacteria generate energy, then the specific example of giant tube worms, and concludes with the overall impact on the food web.
The paragraph flows logically from the general thesis about chemosynthesis at hydrothermal vents, to the biological explanation of specialized bacteria, then to a specific species example (giant tube worms), and finally to the broader ecological conclusion.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the main claim of the paragraph.
The main claim is that hydrothermal vents support thriving ecosystems that depend on chemosynthesis rather than photosynthesis.
This establishes the topic and must be the opening sentence of the paragraph.
2
Find the explanation or evidence that defines the mechanism of chemosynthesis.
The sentence describing specialized bacteria oxidizing hydrogen sulfide to convert it into organic matter explains how chemosynthesis works in this environment.
This directly follows and supports the general claim by detailing the biological process.
3
Identify the concrete example that illustrates this relationship.
The sentence introducing giant tube worms (Riftia pachyptilaRiftia\ pachyptila) as relying on these bacteria inside a trophosome is a specific example.
An example must follow the general explanation of the concept it illustrates.
4
Find the sentence that summarizes the broader ecological impact.
The sentence beginning with 'Consequently' describes how the bacteria serve as the bedrock of the food web.
This serves as a logical conclusion, connecting the specific example of tube worms back to the wider community of crabs, shrimp, and fish.

Key Concept

Supporting Claims with Evidence and Details
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question