Question

Difficulty: HardEvaluating Whole-Essay Goals and Purpose

The Echo of the Wolf

[1] In 1995, after a seventy-year absence, gray wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park. The decision was highly controversial, sparking intense debates between conservationists and local ranchers. Ranchers feared that the predators would devastate livestock populations, while biologists argued that the absence of a keystone predator had severely damaged the park's ecosystem.

[2] In the decades following the wolves' return, biologists witnessed a phenomenon known as a trophic cascade. Without wolves to hunt them, the park's elk population had ballooned, overgrazing young willow, aspen, and cottonwood trees along stream banks. With wolves back on the landscape, elk behavior changed; they spent less time lingering in open valleys where they were vulnerable. Consequently, the vegetation began to recover.

[3] This resurgence of flora triggered a chain reaction. Rebounding trees stabilized riverbanks, reducing erosion and cooling the water, which benefited fish. Beavers returned to build dams, creating wetlands that supported insects, birds, and amphibians. The wolf reintroduction proved that the health of an ecosystem depends on the intricate connections among all its inhabitants.

Statement: Suppose the writer's goal had been to write an essay explaining how the reintroduction of a predator species can trigger a series of environmental changes that benefit other wildlife. This essay successfully achieves that goal.

Answer: Answer

Answer

True
The statement is true because the essay details the positive ecological consequences of the wolf reintroduction. It systematically traces the cause-and-effect pathway from the presence of the predator to changes in elk grazing habits, the subsequent recovery of streamside trees, and the ultimate benefits to other animal species such as fish, beavers, insects, birds, and amphibians.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the proposed writing goal in the statement.
The goal is to explain how reintroducing a predator triggers environmental changes that benefit other wildlife.
This establishes the criteria for evaluating the essay's success.
2
Check if the essay describes the reintroduction of a predator.
Yes, Paragraph 1 introduces the reintroduction of gray wolves, which are predators.
This confirms the starting point of the writer's goal is present.
3
Check if the essay details environmental changes resulting from this reintroduction.
Yes, Paragraph 2 details the trophic cascade, specifically the recovery of streamside vegetation due to changes in elk behavior.
This confirms the intermediate mechanism of environmental change is explained.
4
Check if the essay shows these changes benefit other wildlife.
Yes, Paragraph 3 describes how these changes benefited fish and led to the return of beavers, who created wetlands supporting insects, birds, and amphibians.
This confirms that the final requirement of the goal (benefiting other wildlife) is fulfilled.

Key Concept

Evaluating Whole-Essay Goals and Purpose
Rate this question