Question

Difficulty: MediumRhetorical Function of Specific Word Choices

Read the following passage about the history of the London Underground:

When the Metropolitan Railway opened in London in 1863, skeptics derided the venture as a 'utopian folly,' predicting that passengers would flee the claustrophobic, soot-choked tunnels. Critics did not merely doubt its financial viability; they questioned the psychological capacity of commuters to endure subterranean transit. Yet, this pioneering line did not merely survive; it fundamentally reshaped the metropolitan landscape. The underground railway acted as a civic engine, pulling the sprawling suburbs into a tight orbit around the city center. By transforming transit from a laborious journey into a routine commute, the railway redefined the very boundaries of urban life, proving that the future of the metropolis lay not in outward expansion, but in subterranean connection.

Which of the following best describes how the phrase 'civic engine' functions rhetorically in the passage?

  1. A
    describe the mechanical design and steam power that propelled the early trains.
  2. B
    suggest that the primary purpose of the railway was to alleviate the psychological stress of daily commuters.
  3. emphasize the railway's powerful and active role in unifying the city and its surrounding areas.Answer
  4. D
    contrast the soot-choked conditions inside the tunnels with the cleaner environment of the suburbs.

Answer

The option stating that the phrase emphasizes the railway's powerful and active role in unifying the city and its surrounding areas is the correct answer.
The correct option is correct because the author uses the metaphor of a 'civic engine' to describe how the railway actively pulled suburbs into a tight orbit around the city center. This highlights its role as a powerful force for urban unification and integration.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the targeted phrase 'civic engine' in the context of the passage.
The phrase is found in the sentence: 'The underground railway acted as a civic engine, pulling the sprawling suburbs into a tight orbit around the city center.'
Identifying the immediate context helps determine how the word choice behaves rhetorically.
2
Analyze the figurative meaning and function of the phrase within the sentence.
The word 'civic' relates to the city or citizenry, and 'engine' metaphorically represents a powerful force or driver of action. Together, they describe the railway's action of pulling suburbs closer to the city center, which means it acted as a unifying force.
Connecting the metaphorical language to the surrounding argument reveals its rhetorical purpose.
3
Evaluate the answer choices to find the one that matches this analyzed function and eliminate distractors.
The correct choice aligns with the unifying and driving role of the railway. The other choices either interpret the metaphor literally, distort details about passenger psychology, or create a contrast not present in the text.
Matching the analysis with the options ensures the chosen answer is supported by textual evidence.

Key Concept

Rhetorical Function of Specific Word Choices
Rate this question