Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardAnalyzing Divergent Ideas and Disagreement

Passage A
For generations, the transition from foraging to farming was heralded as humanity’s greatest leap forward. By domesticating plants and animals, early humans secured a reliable food surplus, which in turn catalyzed the rise of sedentary civilizations, division of labor, and technological innovation. Proponents of this traditional narrative point to the rapid population growth and the emergence of monumental architecture as clear evidence that agriculture liberated humanity from the precarious, hand-to-mouth existence of hunter-gatherers. Farming was not merely a change in diet; it was the foundation of human progress, enabling the development of writing, law, and science.

Passage B
The view of the Neolithic Revolution as an unmitigated triumph ignores a wealth of archaeological evidence. Skeletal remains from early agricultural communities reveal a dramatic decline in health compared to their foraging predecessors, characterized by heightened rates of malnutrition, dental decay, and infectious diseases. Rather than liberating humanity, the intense labor required by agriculture locked early societies into a grueling routine, trading a diverse and nutrient-rich wild diet for a monocultural reliance on crops vulnerable to weather and pests. The surplus food did not enrich the average laborer; instead, it fueled social stratification and institutionalized inequality, rendering the shift to farming a historical trap.

Which of the following statements best describes a fundamental point of disagreement between the authors of the two passages?

  1. A
    Whether the transition to farming was accompanied by a shift from nomadic lifestyles to permanent, sedentary settlements.
  2. B
    Whether early agricultural communities relied on a narrower variety of food sources than hunter-gatherers did.
  3. Whether the shift from foraging to farming improved the daily quality of life and health of the average human.Answer
  4. D
    Whether early agricultural societies succeeded in producing a food surplus that allowed for social hierarchy.

Answer

The correct answer states that the fundamental point of disagreement is whether the shift from foraging to farming improved the daily quality of life and health of the average human.
The correct answer is correct because the author of Passage A views the transition from foraging to farming as a liberating development that freed humanity from a precarious existence, while the author of Passage B argues that farming led to a decline in physical health and locked humans into grueling labor. Thus, the two authors disagree on whether the shift improved the daily quality of life and health of the average human.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze Passage A's view on the transition to farming.
Passage A argues that farming domesticated plants/animals, created a reliable surplus, and liberated humanity from a precarious existence, fostering progress.
This establishes the first author's perspective on the Neolithic Revolution.
2
Analyze Passage B's view on the transition to farming.
Passage B counterargues that archaeological evidence shows a decline in health, grueling labor, and inequality, characterizing it as a 'historical trap.'
This establishes the second author's perspective on the Neolithic Revolution.
3
Compare the two viewpoints to find the direct clash.
The clash centers on the physical health, labor, and overall quality of life consequences of the transition for the average person.
Identifying the core point of disagreement yields the correct answer.

Key Concept

Analyzing Divergent Ideas and Disagreement
Estimated Time:2m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Analyzing Divergent Ideas and Disagreement

More questions from this topic