Question

Difficulty: MediumIdentifying Core Claims and Hypotheses

### Origin of Titan's Atmospheric Nitrogen

Titan, Saturn’s largest moon, has a dense, nitrogen-rich atmosphere. Scientists debate the origin of this atmospheric molecular nitrogen (N2N_2).

Hypothesis 1
Titan formed in a warm region of the Saturnian subnebula where molecular nitrogen gas could not condense. Instead, Titan accreted nitrogen primarily in the form of ammonia (NH3NH_3) ice. Over time, internal heating caused the ammonia to outgas into the early atmosphere. Solar ultraviolet (UV) radiation then photolyzed the atmospheric ammonia, splitting it into nitrogen gas (N2N_2) and hydrogen gas (H2H_2). The lighter hydrogen escaped into space, leaving behind a thick layer of N2N_2. Thus, Titan’s atmospheric nitrogen is a secondary product of chemical reactions.

Hypothesis 2
Titan accreted in a much colder region of the Saturnian subnebula, allowing molecular nitrogen (N2N_2) gas to be directly trapped as clathrate hydrates (icy cages) within Titan's silicate and water-ice core during formation. As Titan heated up internally due to radioactive decay, this primordial N2N_2 gas was released directly from the interior into the atmosphere through cryovolcanism. Under this hypothesis, Titan’s atmospheric nitrogen is primordial, having undergone no major chemical conversion from ammonia.

According to Hypothesis 1, which of the following processes was directly responsible for producing the molecular nitrogen (N2N_2) now found in Titan's atmosphere?

  1. The chemical decomposition of outgassed ammonia by solar ultraviolet radiationAnswer
  2. B
    The release of gaseous molecular nitrogen directly from clathrate hydrates in Titan's interior
  3. C
    The chemical conversion of hydrogen gas into molecular nitrogen via planetary cooling
  4. D
    The direct capture of molecular nitrogen from the warm Saturnian subnebula during accretion

Answer

The chemical decomposition of outgassed ammonia by solar ultraviolet radiation
According to Hypothesis 1, Titan accreted ammonia ice because molecular nitrogen could not condense in the warm subnebula. Once this ammonia outgassed, solar ultraviolet radiation photolyzed (chemically decomposed) it into molecular nitrogen and hydrogen gas, forming the current atmosphere. This aligns with the option describing the chemical decomposition of outgassed ammonia by solar ultraviolet radiation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the mechanism of molecular nitrogen production described in Hypothesis 1.
Hypothesis 1 states that solar ultraviolet (UV) radiation photolyzed the atmospheric ammonia, splitting it into nitrogen gas (N2N_2) and hydrogen gas (H2H_2).
This establishes that chemical breakdown of outgassed ammonia is the source of the nitrogen according to Hypothesis 1.
2
Evaluate the options to identify which one represents the photolysis of ammonia.
The option stating 'The chemical decomposition of outgassed ammonia by solar ultraviolet radiation' directly matches this mechanism.
Matching the identified mechanism with the correct option leads to the correct answer.

Key Concept

Identifying Core Claims and Hypotheses
Rate this question