Question

Difficulty: HardRecognizing Explicit Cause and Effect

The bar-headed goose (*Anser indicus*) is renowned for its biannual migration over the Himalayas, a journey that forces the species to fly at altitudes exceeding 8,000 meters. At these elevations, atmospheric pressure is less than half of that at sea level, presenting a severe risk of hypoxia. To combat this, the geese rely on a specialized hemoglobin variant with a high oxygen affinity. This adaptation, which arises from a single amino acid substitution in the alpha-chain of the hemoglobin molecule, allows the birds to extract scarce oxygen from thin mountain air more efficiently than lowland waterfowl. However, this high-affinity hemoglobin binds oxygen so tightly that releasing it to the metabolizing tissues requires a significant drop in blood pH or an increase in body temperature. Consequently, during active flight, the geese do not engage in the typical deep-breathing patterns of other migrating birds; instead, they undergo hyperventilation. The rapid respiration rate lowers the carbon dioxide concentration in their blood, which paradoxically increases blood pH (alkalosis) and shifts the oxygen-dissociation curve, making oxygen release even more difficult. To counteract this potential bottleneck and facilitate oxygen delivery to working flight muscles, the birds rely heavily on localized lactic acid production. The accumulation of lactic acid in active muscle tissues lowers the local pH, which in turn triggers the immediate release of oxygen from the high-affinity hemoglobin directly where it is most needed.

Based on the passage, the immediate release of oxygen from the bar-headed goose's high-affinity hemoglobin to its working flight muscles is directly triggered by which of the following?

  1. The reduction in local pH caused by the accumulation of lactic acid in active musclesAnswer
  2. B
    The sudden release of oxygen from hemoglobin prompting the accumulation of lactic acid in flight tissues
  3. C
    An increase in blood pH resulting from deep-breathing patterns characteristic of lowland waterfowl
  4. D
    A rise in carbon dioxide concentration in the blood following hyperventilation

Answer

The immediate release of oxygen from the high-affinity hemoglobin to working flight muscles is triggered by the reduction in local pH caused by the accumulation of lactic acid in active muscles.
The correct answer accurately reflects the passage's explicit cause-and-effect statement: lactic acid accumulation in active muscle tissues reduces local pH, triggering the release of oxygen from the hemoglobin.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the portion of the passage that explains the mechanism for oxygen release to the flight muscles.
The final sentence states that the accumulation of lactic acid in active muscle tissues lowers the local pH, which triggers the immediate release of oxygen.
This establishes the direct cause (lactic acid lowering local pH) and the direct effect (oxygen release).
2
Identify the option that accurately paraphrases this direct cause-and-effect relationship.
The option describing the reduction in local pH caused by lactic acid accumulation matches the passage details.
To ensure absolute alignment with the literal text without drawing invalid inferences.

Key Concept

Recognizing Explicit Cause and Effect
Rate this question