Question

Difficulty: Very hardFulfilling Specific Rhetorical and Writing Goals

In 1977, NASA launched the twin Voyager spacecraft, each carrying a copper phonograph record plated in gold. A committee chaired by Carl Sagan assembled a diverse collection of sights and sounds to convey a story of our world to any extraterrestrial travelers who might encounter the probes.

The committee faced a daunting challenge, however, in deciding how to represent human biology and civilization without relying on written language. To address this, they included a series of diagrams encoded in analog signals that could be converted into images. These diagrams depicted anatomical drawings of humans, the structure of DNA, and our solar system's location relative to distant pulsars. [Sentence 15] The final selection of images sought to present a hopeful, peaceful portrait of Earth, deliberately omitting depictions of war, disease, or poverty.

The writer wants to insert a sentence at [Sentence 15] that transitions from the technical description of the scientific diagrams to the emotional or philosophical purpose of the record's visual gallery. Which choice most effectively accomplishes this goal?

  1. A
    These pulsars act as cosmic clocks, allowing any finder to determine precisely when the spacecraft was launched.
  2. While these scientific schematics provided objective data, the accompanying photographs aimed to capture the essence of human experience and emotion.Answer
  3. C
    Scientific diagrams offered a technical overview, the photographs instead captured the daily lives and emotions of people across the globe.
  4. D
    Although the scientific schematics conveyed basic biological facts; the visual gallery was designed to portray the spirit of humanity.

Answer

The option stating 'While these scientific schematics provided objective data, the accompanying photographs aimed to capture the essence of human experience and emotion.' is correct because it links the technical details of the diagrams to the emotional purpose of the photograph collection.
The correct option effectively bridges the transition by acknowledging the 'objective data' of the scientific schematics mentioned previously, while introducing the 'human experience and emotion' of the photographs that follow.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the writing goal specified in the prompt.
The goal is to find a transition from the technical description of scientific diagrams (anatomy, DNA, pulsars) to the emotional or philosophical purpose of the visual gallery (a hopeful, peaceful portrait).
Understanding the precise transition required is necessary to evaluate the options.
2
Evaluate the choices for grammatical correctness.
The option containing a comma splice ('Scientific diagrams offered... , the photographs instead...') and the option containing a semicolon error ('Although... ;') are grammatically incorrect.
Eliminating grammatically incorrect options narrows the choices to those that are syntactically valid.
3
Determine which grammatically correct option satisfies the rhetorical goal.
The option starting with 'While these scientific schematics' explicitly bridges the 'objective data' of the schematics with the 'human experience and emotion' of the photographs.
Selecting the option that connects both the preceding technical context and the subsequent emotional context ensures a smooth transition.

Key Concept

Selecting transitional sentences that fulfill specific rhetorical and writing goals.
Rate this question