Question

Difficulty: MediumEvaluating Whole-Essay Goals and Purpose

The following is an essay about a late-nineteenth-century invention:

[1]
In the late nineteenth century, the introduction of the safety bicycle revolutionized personal mobility. Unlike its predecessor, the "ordinary" or "penny-farthing"—which featured a massive front wheel, lacked brakes, and posed a constant threat of header crashes—the safety bicycle boasted two equal-sized wheels, a chain drive, and pneumatic tires. Cycling was no longer a dangerous stunt reserved for athletic young men; it became an accessible, comfortable activity for the general public.

[2]
Perhaps no group was more profoundly affected by this technological shift than women. For decades, societal norms restricted women's independence, confining their travel largely to distances they could walk or journeys chaperoned in carriages. The safety bicycle provided an unprecedented means of self-locomotion. Susan B. Anthony famously remarked that bicycling had "done more to emancipate women than anything else in the world," giving them a feeling of freedom and self-reliance.

[3]
The bicycle also drove significant changes in women's fashion. To ride comfortably, women abandoned heavy, restrictive Victorian corsets and voluminous skirts in favor of "rational dress," which included bloomers and shorter skirts. Although conservative critics decried these changes as scandalous, the practicality of the bicycle triumphed. In this way, the safety bicycle did not merely change how people traveled; it reshaped the social fabric of the era.

Suppose the writer’s goal had been to write an essay that traces the mechanical evolution of the bicycle from its earliest prototypes to modern designs. Would this essay accomplish that goal?

  1. A
    Yes, because it describes the transition from the penny-farthing to the safety bicycle and lists several key mechanical components.
  2. B
    Yes, because it explains how improvements in bicycle design eventually led to the development of motorized vehicles.
  3. No, because the essay focuses primarily on the social and cultural effects of the safety bicycle, particularly regarding women’s independence and clothing.Answer
  4. D
    No, because the essay argues that the safety bicycle was too expensive and dangerous for most people to use.

Answer

No, because the essay focuses primarily on the social and cultural effects of the safety bicycle, particularly regarding women’s independence and clothing.
The essay does not accomplish the proposed goal. While the first paragraph touches on the mechanical differences between the penny-farthing and the safety bicycle, the majority of the essay is dedicated to explaining how the safety bicycle impacted women's social independence and fashion choices. Therefore, the correct choice is the option stating that the essay does not accomplish the goal because it focuses primarily on these social and cultural effects.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the proposed writing goal in the prompt.
The goal is to trace the mechanical evolution of the bicycle from earliest prototypes to modern designs.
Understanding the goal is necessary to evaluate the essay against it.
2
Analyze the main focus and contents of the provided essay.
The essay discusses the safety bicycle's introduction, its impact on women's independence, and the resulting changes in women's fashion.
Evaluating the actual content of the essay reveals whether the goal was met.
3
Compare the proposed goal with the actual content of the essay.
The essay does not trace mechanical evolution to modern designs; it focuses on social and cultural effects. Thus, the essay does not fulfill the goal.
Making this comparison allows for selecting the correct 'No' option with the accurate explanation.

Key Concept

Evaluating Whole-Essay Goals and Purpose
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question