Question

Difficulty: Very hardComprehending Explicit Comparisons and Contrasts

Passage:
While both hydrothermal vents and cold seeps support unique chemosynthetic ecosystems independent of sunlight, their physical environments and biological dynamics differ. Hydrothermal vents, typically found along mid-ocean ridges, are characterized by high-temperature (often exceeding 350C350^\circ\text{C}), mineral-rich fluids venting violently from the crust. In contrast, cold seeps occur along continental margins, where lower-temperature fluids containing hydrocarbons like methane and hydrogen sulfide diffuse slowly through seafloor sediments. A primary biological distinction lies in the role of symbiotic relationships: hydrothermal vent ecosystems are heavily dominated by giant tube worms (*Riftia pachyptila*) that lack a digestive tract and rely entirely on endosymbiotic bacteria to oxidize sulfide. Cold seep communities, conversely, are typically dominated by vesicomyid clams and bathymodiolin mussels. While these seep bivalves also harbor symbiotic bacteria, they retain a functional digestive tract, allowing them to supplement their chemosynthetic diet by filter-feeding on organic matter suspended in the water column—a capability entirely absent in the vent tube worms.

According to the passage, what is an explicitly stated difference between the biological capabilities of the dominant organisms found at cold seeps and those found at hydrothermal vents?

  1. A
    While hydrothermal vent tube worms depend on endosymbiotic bacteria to oxidize sulfide, cold seep bivalves survive without chemosynthetic endosymbionts by relying solely on filter-feeding of organic matter suspended in the water column.
  2. Unlike the tube worms dominant at hydrothermal vents, which rely exclusively on endosymbiotic bacteria due to their lack of a digestive tract, the dominant bivalves at cold seeps possess a functional digestive system that enables them to supplement their nutrition via filter-feeding.Answer
  3. C
    The bivalves dominant in cold seeps reside in lower-temperature environments along mid-ocean ridges, whereas the tube worms dominant in hydrothermal vents are restricted to high-temperature fluids along continental margins.
  4. D
    Although both ecosystems rely on chemosynthesis, hydrothermal vent tube worms must actively filter-feed on organic matter to supplement their diet, whereas cold seep bivalves rely entirely on endosymbiotic bacteria to process diffused hydrocarbons.

Answer

Unlike the tube worms dominant at hydrothermal vents, which rely exclusively on endosymbiotic bacteria due to their lack of a digestive tract, the dominant bivalves at cold seeps possess a functional digestive system that enables them to supplement their nutrition via filter-feeding.
The correct answer accurately states the explicit contrast described in the passage: giant tube worms in hydrothermal vent ecosystems lack a digestive tract and depend entirely on symbiotic bacteria, whereas cold seep bivalves retain functional digestive tracts that allow them to supplement their diet through filter-feeding.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the passage to locate the comparison between the biological properties of hydrothermal vent tube worms and cold seep bivalves.
The passage states that hydrothermal vent tube worms lack a digestive tract and rely entirely on endosymbiotic bacteria, while cold seep bivalves retain a functional digestive tract that allows them to supplement their diet through filter-feeding.
Establishing what the text explicitly states about each organism's anatomy and nutrition is necessary to identify the correct contrast.
2
Evaluate the answer choices to find the one that accurately restates this explicit comparison without introducing distortions or reversing details.
The option stating that seep bivalves have functional digestive systems to supplement nutrition via filter-feeding while vent tube worms lack them entirely is a direct and accurate paraphrase.
This step ensures that the selected option aligns with the literal information presented in the text.

Key Concept

Identifying explicitly stated similarities and differences between two subjects in a text
Estimated Time:2m 30s
Rate this question