Question

Difficulty: Very hardRecognizing Explicit Cause and Effect

For decades, paleoclimatologists analyzing the sudden temperature drop of the Younger Dryas period—approximately 12,900 years ago—pointed to the catastrophic draining of Lake Agassiz as the primary instigator. According to this traditional model, the sudden influx of freshwater disrupted the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) by reducing the salinity and density of surface waters in the North Atlantic, which in turn halted the northward transport of heat. However, recent sediment core analyses have revealed that this freshwater pulse actually preceded the oceanic slowdown by nearly three centuries. Instead, the immediate catalyst for the AMOC disruption appears to have been a prolonged period of intense atmospheric cooling driven by volcanic aerosols, which cooled the surface waters to the point of freezing. The resulting sea-ice expansion acted as a thermal barrier, preventing wind-driven mixing and thereby directly precipitating the stagnation of the deep-water circulation. The draining of Lake Agassiz, rather than initiating the cooling event, was actually triggered later when the advancing Laurentide Ice Sheet blocked alternative northern drainage routes and forced the lake to overflow its southern margins, creating a feedback loop that merely prolonged the pre-existing cold period.

According to the passage, the stagnation of deep-water circulation in the North Atlantic was directly precipitated by which of the following?

  1. A
    A disruption in the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) that triggered volcanic aerosol emissions
  2. The expansion of sea ice acting as a thermal barrier that prevented wind-driven mixingAnswer
  3. C
    The catastrophic draining of Lake Agassiz, which reduced the salinity of surface ocean waters
  4. D
    The advancement of the Laurentide Ice Sheet, which blocked northern ocean currents

Answer

The stagnation of deep-water circulation was directly caused by the expansion of sea ice acting as a thermal barrier that prevented wind-driven mixing.
The correct answer is supported by the text, which explicitly states that the stagnation of the deep-water circulation was directly precipitated by the sea-ice expansion acting as a thermal barrier and preventing wind-driven mixing.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the key effect in the question stem.
The target effect is the 'stagnation of deep-water circulation'.
The question asks what directly precipitated this specific stagnation event.
2
Locate the mention of this effect in the passage.
The passage states: 'The resulting sea-ice expansion acted as a thermal barrier, preventing wind-driven mixing and thereby directly precipitating the stagnation of the deep-water circulation.'
This sentence explicitly links the cause (sea-ice expansion acting as a thermal barrier and preventing mixing) to the effect (stagnation of the deep-water circulation).
3
Evaluate the options against this explicit cause-and-effect relationship.
The correct option is the one stating that sea-ice expansion blocked wind-driven mixing by acting as a thermal barrier.
It directly matches the literal explanation provided in the text.

Key Concept

Identifying explicitly stated causal relationships within a complex text containing competing models.
Rate this question