Question

Difficulty: MediumRhetorical Functions of Sentences and Paragraphs

For decades, agricultural historians assumed that the transition to sedentary farming in the Fertile Crescent was driven solely by sudden climatic drying. Recently, however, archaeologist Arlene Rosen examined phytoliths—microscopic silica structures from ancient plants—at several Epipaleolithic sites. She found that the plants cultivated during the transition thrived in wet, marshy conditions rather than arid ones. This discovery disrupted the established narrative of climate-driven desperation. By demonstrating that early cultivation occurred during a period of ecological abundance, Rosen’s work suggested that the shift to agriculture was a deliberate choice enabled by surplus, rather than a desperate response to starvation.

Based on the passage, which of the following best describes the primary rhetorical function of the sentence "This discovery disrupted the established narrative of climate-driven desperation"?

  1. A
    explain the physical process by which silica structures are formed in cultivated plants
  2. B
    state that early agricultural societies suffered from severe food shortages due to drought
  3. identify the impact of Rosen's findings on a long-standing historical assumptionAnswer
  4. D
    introduce a new hypothesis about why the Fertile Crescent experienced sudden climatic drying

Answer

identify the impact of Rosen's findings on a long-standing historical assumption
The correct answer correctly identifies that the sentence functions to explain how Rosen's archaeological findings challenged the traditional historical consensus that agricultural development was triggered by climate drying.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the targeted sentence in context.
The target sentence states: "This discovery disrupted the established narrative of climate-driven desperation." "This discovery" refers back to Rosen's findings on phytoliths showing wet-plant cultivation, and the "established narrative" refers to the agricultural historians' assumption that farming was driven by drying.
Understanding the context of the sentence is essential to determine its rhetorical function.
2
Determine the relationship between the target sentence and the rest of the passage.
The sentence links the archaeological findings (which showed wet-condition plants) with the broader historical theory (that climate drying forced farming). It asserts that the new findings invalidated the old theory.
Rhetorical function is defined by how a sentence relates to surrounding arguments or assertions.
3
Evaluate the options to identify which one correctly describes this relationship.
The option stating that it identifies the impact of Rosen's findings on a long-standing historical assumption directly aligns with this analysis.
Selecting the option that matches the structural role of the sentence confirms the correct answer.

Key Concept

Identifying the rhetorical role or structural function of a specific sentence within a passage's argument
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question