Question

Difficulty: EasyArgument Development and Evidence Sequencing

For centuries, scientific consensus held that all life on Earth was ultimately sustained by sunlight. Through photosynthesis, plants and algae converted solar radiation into chemical energy, forming the indispensable base of the global food web. Even the most remote organisms, dwelling in the abyssal depths of the ocean where light never penetrates, were believed to depend on a slow, downward drift of organic debris—commonly referred to as 'marine snow'—originating from the sunlit surface waters. This established paradigm, however, was fundamentally challenged in 1977 during an expedition to the Galapagos Rift, a volcanic ridge on the Pacific Ocean floor.

Using the deep-sea submersible Alvin, oceanographers discovered hydrothermal vents—fissures in the ocean floor that spewed superheated, mineral-rich water into the freezing depths. To the scientists’ astonishment, these vents were surrounded by dense, thriving communities of organisms, including giant tube worms, blind crabs, and massive clusters of clams. Because these ecosystems existed in complete darkness, thousands of meters below the reach of sunlight, they could not rely on photosynthesis. This striking observation forced researchers to seek an alternative explanation for how such a high concentration of biomass could be supported in an otherwise barren environment.

Subsequent water analysis revealed the key to this mystery: an abundance of hydrogen sulfide, a chemical compound highly toxic to most terrestrial life. Researchers hypothesized that specialized bacteria were utilizing this compound to produce energy through chemosynthesis—a process in which chemical energy, rather than light energy, is used to convert carbon molecules into organic matter. To test this hypothesis, scientists collected bacterial samples from the vent chimneys and cultivated them in laboratory environments. They confirmed that these microbes thrived by oxidizing hydrogen sulfide, effectively serving as the primary producers for the entire ecosystem. The discovery of chemosynthesis not only redefined the biological boundaries of life on Earth but also expanded the search for potential life on ice-covered moons in the outer solar system, where subsurface oceans are heated by geothermal activity rather than solar radiation.

According to the passage, for what primary reason does the author reference 'marine snow' in the first paragraph?

  1. To illustrate the traditional scientific assumption that all deep-sea life depended on organic material from the sunlit surface.Answer
  2. B
    To argue that hydrothermal vent communities rely on organic debris rather than chemosynthesis.
  3. C
    To prove that solar radiation can penetrate to the deepest areas of the ocean floor.
  4. D
    To summarize the main argument of the passage regarding the limits of terrestrial ecosystems.

Answer

The reference to marine snow is used to illustrate the traditional scientific assumption that all deep-sea life depended on organic material from the sunlit surface.
The author mentions 'marine snow' to show how scientists explained deep-sea life within the old, sun-dependent framework, illustrating the baseline paradigm before it was challenged by the Galapagos Rift expedition.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the reference to 'marine snow' in the first paragraph of the passage.
The text states that deep-sea organisms were believed to depend on a downward drift of organic debris, commonly called 'marine snow,' which originated from sunlit waters.
Finding the specific context helps identify how the author uses this detail to set up the starting point of the scientific discussion.
2
Analyze the role of this detail within the paragraph's overall structure.
The paragraph introduces marine snow to explain how scientists accounted for deep-sea life under the old paradigm where all life was assumed to be sun-dependent.
This establishes the baseline scientific paradigm that the rest of the passage's narrative will challenge.
3
Compare this role with the options to identify the one that correctly describes it.
The option describing it as illustrating the traditional scientific assumption that deep-sea life relied on surface nutrients matches this analysis.
This selects the correct answer by linking the rhetorical function of the evidence to the overall argument development.

Key Concept

Argument Development and Evidence Sequencing
Rate this question