Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumParagraph-Level Transitions

The following paragraphs are from an essay about the invention and history of the saxophone. To make the essay flow most logically, in what order should the paragraphs be arranged?

  1. 1In the early 1840s, Belgian instrument maker Adolphe Sax set out to address a common frustration among composers: the acoustic gap between woodwinds and brasses. Woodwinds possessed agility and tonal warmth but lacked volume, while brass instruments offered power but were often rigid and difficult to play softly. Sax envisioned a new instrument that would combine the best qualities of both families.
  2. 2To realize this vision, Sax engineered a hybrid design, pairing a clarinet-like single-reed mouthpiece with a conical brass body. This combination allowed for a highly responsive key system similar to an oboe or flute, but with the acoustic projection of a brass horn. In 1846, Sax patented this creation, naming it the saxophone, and anticipated its widespread adoption in both military bands and classical orchestras.
  3. 3While military bands readily embraced the saxophone for its outdoor carrying power, classical orchestras proved far more resistant. Many conservative European composers and conductors viewed the instrument as an unnecessary novelty that clashed with the established, delicate balance of traditional string and woodwind sections. Consequently, Sax's invention struggled to find a permanent home in mainstream orchestral music.
  4. 4This initial rejection, however, did not seal the saxophone's fate. Decades later and thousands of miles away, the instrument found its true calling in the United States. During the early twentieth century, American musicians recognized the saxophone's unique capacity for vocal-like expression, turning it into the defining sound of a burgeoning new genre: jazz.

Answer

The paragraphs should be arranged in the sequence starting with Adolphe Sax's vision to bridge the gap between instrument families, followed by the hybrid brass and woodwind design of the instrument, then the rejection of the instrument by traditional European classical orchestras, and concluding with its adoption and success in American jazz.
The correct order follows a clear chronological and logical progression. The first paragraph introduces Sax's goal to bridge the gap between woodwinds and brasses. The second paragraph begins with 'To realize this vision,' describing the creation of the saxophone and its anticipated use in military and classical domains. The third paragraph picks up on this anticipation by contrasting the immediate embrace of the instrument by military bands with the rejection from classical orchestras. The final paragraph transitions from this rejection with the phrase 'This initial rejection, however,' to describe the saxophone's ultimate success in American jazz.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the introductory paragraph that establishes the main topic and does not rely on prior context.
The paragraph introducing Adolphe Sax and his goal to bridge the gap between woodwinds and brasses is the logical starting point, as it contains no transitional words referring to previous text.
An essay must begin by defining its subject and setting up the central theme before details can be developed.
2
Look for explicit transition words or phrases that link paragraphs together.
The phrase 'To realize this vision' at the beginning of the hybrid design paragraph directly connects to Sax's 'vision' mentioned at the end of the introductory paragraph.
Cohesion requires that sentences or paragraphs referencing specific ideas must immediately follow where those ideas are introduced.
3
Trace the logical progression of the remaining paragraphs using parallel structures and contrasting ideas.
The design paragraph ends by mentioning both military bands and classical orchestras. The rejection paragraph begins by contrasting these two: 'While military bands readily embraced... classical orchestras proved far more resistant.'
Paragraphs that elaborate on specific sub-topics introduced in preceding sentences must follow them to maintain structural unity.
4
Confirm the final paragraph's transition and ensure the narrative reaches a logical conclusion.
The jazz paragraph begins with 'This initial rejection, however,' which directly refers to the struggle and rejection described in the preceding paragraph, bringing the history to a successful modern resolution.
The final transition resolves the tension of the previous paragraph, transitioning from rejection to ultimate success.

Key Concept

Paragraph-Level Transitions
Rate this question

Topics

Paragraph-Level Transitions

More questions from this topic