Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardBlack Feminist and Womanist Movements

Read the following excerpt from the Combahee River Collective Statement (1977):

> 'We struggle together with Black men against racial oppression, while we also struggle with Black men about sexist oppression.'

Which of the following statements best analyzes how this position distinguished the Combahee River Collective's ideology from both mainstream second-wave white feminism and contemporary Black nationalist movements?

  1. It rejected the gender-separatist tendencies of mainstream white feminism by affirming political solidarity with Black men against racism, while simultaneously challenging the patriarchal structures within Black liberation movements that marginalized women's struggles.Answer
  2. B
    It aligned with mainstream second-wave feminism by asserting that gender oppression is the primary contradiction in society and must be resolved before addressing racial inequities, thereby distancing the group from Black nationalist organizations.
  3. C
    It embraced the mainstream second-wave feminist assumption of a universal female experience, asserting that the struggles of Black women and white women against patriarchy were identical.
  4. D
    It endorsed the dominant Black nationalist position that internal community critiques of sexism should be suppressed until racial liberation is achieved, arguing that public critique of Black men would weaken the anti-racist struggle.

Answer

The correct answer is the option stating that the Combahee River Collective rejected the gender-separatist tendencies of mainstream white feminism by affirming political solidarity with Black men against racism, while simultaneously challenging the patriarchal structures within Black liberation movements that marginalized women's struggles.
The correct answer accurately captures the intersectional framework of the Combahee River Collective. By stating they struggle with Black men against racism, they reject the separatist stance of some mainstream white feminist organizations that excluded men. By stating they struggle with Black men about sexism, they reject the patriarchal expectations of Black nationalist groups that pressured women to silence critiques of sexism for the sake of racial unity.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus quote to identify the dual focus of the Combahee River Collective's struggle.
The quote shows a dual commitment: working 'together with' Black men against racism, and struggling 'about sexist oppression' with those same men.
This establishes that the group does not view Black men as absolute adversaries (unlike some separatist feminist movements) nor does it ignore internal community sexism (unlike some Black nationalist movements).
2
Compare the identified stance with mainstream second-wave white feminism of the late 1970s.
Second-wave white feminism often assumed a universal female experience and sometimes advocated for separatism from men, which contrasted with the Collective's insistence on anti-racist solidarity with Black men.
This helps rule out options that claim the Collective shared a universalist or separatist gender-first approach.
3
Compare the identified stance with contemporary Black nationalist movements.
Black nationalist movements of the era frequently prioritized racial struggle and demanded that internal gender critiques be deferred, which directly contrasts with the Collective's insistence on active struggle against internal sexism.
This helps rule out options suggesting the Collective deferred gender critiques for the sake of racial unity.

Key Concept

The intersectional politics of Black Feminist movements, specifically how they navigate solidarity and critique in relation to both white feminism and Black nationalism.
Rate this question

Topics

Black Feminist and Womanist Movements

More questions from this topic