Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardThe Black Power Movement

Read the following excerpt from Stokely Carmichael and Charles V. Hamilton’s book *Black Power: The Politics of Liberation* (1967):

'Before a group can enter the open society, it must first close ranks. By this we mean that group solidarity is a necessary assumption before a group with a low status can negotiate a position of strength in a pluralistic society. The world is still structured along the lines of coalition of groups, not individuals.'

Which of the following developments best illustrates the implementation of the strategy described in the excerpt?

  1. Establishing community-controlled institutions, such as the Black Panther Party’s survival programs, to build collective self-reliance before negotiating with the state.Answer
  2. B
    Forming immediate political coalitions with white-led labor unions and major political parties to push for national civil rights legislation.
  3. C
    Advocating for the total dissolution of racial identity to facilitate the seamless assimilation of Black individuals into mainstream institutions.
  4. D
    Organizing mass migration initiatives to relocate African Americans to newly independent African nations to build a separate global power base.

Answer

Establishing community-controlled institutions, such as the Black Panther Party’s survival programs, to build collective self-reliance before negotiating with the state.
The correct option correctly identifies the implementation of 'closing ranks' through the establishment of independent, community-controlled programs and institutions (such as the Black Panther Party's Free Breakfast for Children Program and community health clinics). This aligns with the authors' argument that Black Americans had to build independent socio-economic and political strength within their own communities before they could negotiate with the wider pluralistic society from a position of equal power.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the excerpt’s central thesis regarding group dynamics.
Determine that the authors argue that marginalized groups must establish internal cohesion ('close ranks') and collective strength before they can successfully integrate or negotiate in a pluralistic society.
Understanding the theory of group solidarity as a prerequisite for power is necessary to evaluate the options.
2
Examine the historical strategies of the Black Power movement.
Identify that the movement focused on self-determination, community control of schools and businesses, and local survival programs.
Connecting theory to practice helps locate historical examples of 'closing ranks'.
3
Compare the options against the concept of establishing internal group strength before external negotiation.
The creation of independent, community-controlled institutions matches the concept of closing ranks, while coalitions with mainstream groups, assimilation, or emigration either bypass this step or reject domestic negotiation entirely.
This identifies the option that correctly applies Carmichael and Hamilton's framework.

Key Concept

The strategy of self-determination and community control within the Black Power Movement
Rate this question

Topics

The Black Power Movement

More questions from this topic