Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumBooker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois Debate

Read the following excerpt from W.E.B. Du Bois's essay 'The Talented Tenth' (1903):

'If we make money the object of man-training, we shall develop money-makers but not necessarily men; if we make technical skill the object of education, we may provide bread-winners but we will not develop those who will guide and elevate society.'

Based on the excerpt, which of the following best describes how Du Bois's educational philosophy differed from that of Booker T. Washington?

  1. Du Bois believed that higher education in the liberal arts was essential to develop leaders who could secure civil rights, while Washington emphasized practical vocational training for economic self-sufficiency, though both sought the long-term advancement of African Americans.Answer
  2. B
    Du Bois rejected the value of industrial and agricultural education entirely, whereas Washington argued that vocational training was the sole method necessary for achieving full citizenship.
  3. C
    Du Bois argued that Black advancement depended solely on securing immediate economic gains before pursuing political power, whereas Washington maintained that political agitation must come first.
  4. D
    Du Bois favored immediate emigration and building separate international institutions, whereas Washington advocated for immediate, complete social integration within the American South.

Answer

Du Bois believed that higher education in the liberal arts was essential to develop leaders who could secure civil rights, while Washington emphasized practical vocational training for economic self-sufficiency, though both sought the long-term advancement of African Americans.
The correct answer accurately states that Du Bois emphasized classical liberal arts education to develop an intellectual leadership class (the 'Talented Tenth') capable of fighting for civil rights, which contrasted with Washington's emphasis on industrial education and economic self-sufficiency. Crucially, it avoids oversimplification by noting that both leaders ultimately shared the goal of elevating the African American community.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided excerpt from Du Bois's 'The Talented Tenth' (1903).
The text critiques an educational model focused solely on 'technical skill' and 'money-making' (vocational training), arguing that it fails to develop 'those who will guide and elevate society' (intellectual leaders).
This establishes Du Bois's perspective that a purely vocational focus is insufficient for comprehensive racial advancement.
2
Compare Du Bois's argument in the excerpt with Booker T. Washington's known educational philosophy.
Washington championed vocational and industrial education (e.g., at Tuskegee Institute) as the primary means for African Americans to achieve economic independence and eventually win respect and rights, whereas Du Bois advocated for classical, liberal arts education to prepare a leadership class.
Identifying this contrast allows for distinguishing the correct educational philosophies of both figures.
3
Identify the option that accurately captures the ideological differences without reducing their relationship to a simplified, absolute zero-sum conflict.
The correct option highlights the difference in their primary educational strategies (liberal arts/leadership vs. vocational/economic) while acknowledging their shared, overlapping goal of African American advancement.
This aligns with the historical nuance that both leaders wanted racial progress but differed on the methodology.

Key Concept

Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois Debate
Rate this question

Topics

Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois Debate

More questions from this topic