Question

Difficulty: MediumContrasts and Tonal Shifts

Read the following poem:

Within these panes of glass, a false July
Preserves the orchid’s tongue, the fern’s green feather,
Beneath a high, manufactured sky
That locks out winter’s blade and biting weather.
Here, safe from frost, the heavy blossoms sigh,
Shedding their pollen in a stagnant room,
Content to bloom and scent the air, while I
Admire the neat defiance of their bloom.

Yet pressing close against the steamed-up glass,
The skeletal grey branches of the oak
Mock this small refuge where the hours pass
In sweet simulation, like a gilded yoke;
For outside, in the cold, the wild things die,
But dying, feed the earth that gives them birth,
While here, embalmed in heat, the lilies lie,
Denied the soil, the struggle, and the earth.

In the poem, the speaker’s attitude toward the conservatory undergoes a shift that is best described as a transition from which of the following?

  1. A
    literal categorization of the flora to a figurative comparison using personification
  2. B
    consistent admiration of its ability to defy the destructive forces of winter
  3. C
    personal pride in the poet’s own ability to write poetry that preserves life to a sense of guilt over neglecting the outside world
  4. appreciation of its protective warmth to a realization of its sterile confinementAnswer
  5. E
    observing the physical structure of the glass panes to describing the outdoor winter weather

Answer

appreciation of its protective warmth to a realization of its sterile confinement
The correct answer is correct because the speaker begins by admiring the conservatory as a refuge that 'locks out winter’s blade' and preserves beauty, but shifts in the ninth line ('Yet...') to view it as a 'gilded yoke' and 'embalmed,' recognizing that its safety comes at the cost of genuine growth and natural cycles.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the speaker's initial depiction of the conservatory in lines 1-8.
The conservatory is described as a protective space ('safe from frost', 'locks out winter’s blade') that the speaker looks upon with admiration ('Admire the neat defiance').
Establishing the initial tone and attitude sets the baseline for measuring the shift.
2
Identify the transition point in the poem and analyze the shift in imagery.
The turn occurs in line 9 with the word 'Yet,' which introduces the outside oak branches that 'Mock this small refuge' and compares the conservatory to a 'gilded yoke' and a state of being 'embalmed.'
Pinpointing where the shift occurs reveals the contrast between the interior and exterior environments.
3
Synthesize the contrast to determine the thematic shift in attitude.
The speaker concludes that the conservatory's plants are 'denied the soil, the struggle, and the earth,' indicating a shift from valuing their safety to criticizing their isolation from genuine natural cycles.
This step determines the final emotional and thematic resolution of the speaker's attitude.

Key Concept

Contrasts and Tonal Shifts
Rate this question