Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardSymbolism and Motifs

Read the following poem carefully:

The Salt-Garden

We sowed the grey seed in a brackish clay,
Where no sweet spring had ever dared to run,
And watched the pale crust ripen day by day,
A sterile harvest bleaching in the sun.
At first we praised the glitter of the white,
That sparkled like a host of fallen stars,
A clean, cold armor shielding us from night,
More durable than oak or iron bars.
But when the wind blew bitter from the reef,
It bit the root and stung the weeping eye;
The salt became our bread, our wine, our grief,
The very soil in which our dreams must die.

In the poem, the development of the salt motif—from a "clean, cold armor" (line 7) to "our bread, our wine, our grief" (line 11)—primarily serves to convey which of the following ideas?

  1. A protective barrier established against external adversity can eventually become a source of internal desolation.Answer
  2. B
    Salt acts as a universal agent of spiritual purification and moral cleansing for a community that has lost its way.
  3. C
    The speakers face insurmountable environmental challenges when attempting to cultivate edible crops in coastal soils.
  4. D
    The speakers maintain an unwavering admiration for the stark beauty and permanent strength of the coastal landscape.
  5. E
    The poet is expressing their personal grief over their failed efforts to establish an agricultural cooperative in Victorian England.

Answer

A protective barrier established against external adversity can eventually become a source of internal desolation.
The correct answer is supported by the trajectory of the salt motif in the poem. In the second stanza, the speakers view the salt as "armor shielding us from night," representing an external, protective barrier against the outside world. By the final stanza, however, this barrier has permeated their existence, becoming their daily sustenance ("our bread, our wine") and the source of their suffering ("our grief"), showing that their defensive isolation has turned inward and desolated them.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the initial description and symbolic function of the salt in the first two stanzas.
The speakers describe the salt-garden as a "sterile harvest" but praise its glitter ("fallen stars") and view it as a "clean, cold armor" shielding them from the night. This establishes salt as a symbol of protection, isolation, and static defense.
Understanding the starting point of the symbol's trajectory is necessary to track its evolution.
2
Identify the shift in tone and imagery that occurs in the final stanza.
The introduction of the bitter wind ("bit the root", "stung the weeping eye") marks a turn from admiration to pain. The salt transitions from a protective exterior shield to an internal presence ("our bread, our wine") associated with mourning ("our grief") and death ("dreams must die").
Tracing the structural and thematic shift in the poem reveals the changing nature of the motif.
3
Synthesize the transition of the salt symbol to determine its primary conceptual meaning.
The progression from an external "armor" to an all-consuming internal diet of "grief" demonstrates that the defensive isolation the speakers built to protect themselves has ultimately poisoned their inner lives.
Synthesizing the motif's evolution directly answers how the symbolic shift conveys the central theme.

Key Concept

Thematic evolution of a central motif over the course of a poem
Estimated Time:3m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Symbolism and Motifs

More questions from this topic