Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumCharacter Relationships and Conflict

Read the following passage from Edith Wharton’s 1920 novel *The Age of Innocence* carefully before choosing the best answer.

“I want to be free; to be like the others,” she said.
“To do what, Countess Olenska?” Archer asked, his voice sounding thin and far-off to himself.
“To be free!” she repeated, her eyes filling with tears. “To get away from it all—from the horror, the lie, the loneliness! You don't know what it is, Newland. You've always lived here, in this safe, clean, pleasant world. You don't know what it's like to be hunted, to be tortured, to be made to feel that everything you do is a crime!”
Archer felt a sudden, overwhelming wave of pity and anger. He leaned forward, taking her hand. “Ellen,” he said, “I do know. Or at least, I can guess. And I want to help you. But you must understand that New York isn't the free place you think it is. In some ways, it's more rigid, more demanding than the world you've left. It's a small society, Ellen, and it's governed by rules that are all the more powerful because they're never spoken.”
“Rules?” she said, looking at him with a sort of childlike wonder. “But what rules? What have I done that is wrong? I only want to live quietly, to forget the past.”
“It's not what you've done,” Archer said gently. “It's what you represent. You've come back from a world that New York fears and despises, a world of passion and scandal. And by coming back, you've brought that world with you. They don't want to be reminded of it, Ellen. They want to keep their own lives safe and undisturbed.”

Which of the following best characterizes the conflict between Countess Olenska and Newland Archer in this passage?

  1. A
    It is a straightforward moral conflict between the Countess's corrupt European past and Archer's defense of traditional American virtue.
  2. B
    It serves to demonstrate the author's direct endorsement of Archer's warning as the only valid moral perspective on New York society.
  3. It represents a clash between the Countess's idealistic view of New York as a refuge of personal freedom and Archer's realistic understanding of its unspoken, rigid social codes.Answer
  4. D
    It documents the sequential events of the Countess's escape from Europe and her subsequent introduction to New York's upper class.
  5. E
    It functions as a dramatic soliloquy where the characters speak directly to the audience to reveal their hidden motivations.

Answer

The conflict between Countess Olenska and Newland Archer represents a clash between the Countess's idealistic view of New York as a refuge of personal freedom and Archer's realistic understanding of its unspoken, rigid social codes.
The correct answer identifies that the conflict arises from the clash between Countess Olenska's longing for personal freedom and Newland Archer's understanding that New York is governed by rigid, unspoken rules. She views the city as a refuge where she can escape her past, while Archer recognizes that Gilded Age society is highly restrictive and demands conformity.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze Countess Olenska's perspective on New York society in the passage.
She expresses a desire to be 'free' and escape 'the horror, the lie, the loneliness,' believing New York represents safety and a fresh start.
This establishes her motivation and her initial assumption about the environment she has entered.
2
Analyze Newland Archer's response and explanation of New York's structure.
He warns her that New York is not free, explaining that it is 'more rigid, more demanding' and governed by powerful, 'never spoken' rules that reject what she represents.
This shows his realistic, insider understanding of his society's constraints, which contradicts her expectations.
3
Synthesize the two viewpoints to identify the primary source of their conflict.
The tension arises from the clash between her desire for individual freedom and his recognition that the society's unspoken codes will not tolerate what she represents.
This synthesis allows us to identify the option that accurately captures the complex social and psychological dynamic between the characters.

Key Concept

Analyzing character relationships and social conflicts in longer fiction through dialogue and subtext.
Rate this question

Topics

Character Relationships and Conflict

More questions from this topic