Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardNarrator Identification and Perspective

Read the following passage carefully:

We watched Mr. Abernathy through the frosted glass of the sorting room, his silhouette performing the same angular sequence of movements he had repeated since the Treaty of Utrecht. To the town, he was a monument of clerkish devotion, a man who had traded the messy vitality of a family for the quiet permanence of ledger books. He believed we respected this sacrifice. In truth, we stood there not in awe of his diligence, but in anticipation of his collapse. We counted the seconds between his ink-dips, noting how the nib lingered a fraction longer each Tuesday, a minute decay we documented with the same cold precision he applied to the municipal archives. When he finally looked up, his eyes glassy and seeking ours for approval, we withdrew into the shadows, leaving him to address the empty hallway.

Which of the following best characterizes the narrator's perspective regarding Mr. Abernathy?

  1. A collective observer whose outward compliance masks a detached and expectant scrutiny of his declineAnswer
  2. B
    An omniscient reporter who objectively details the psychological toll of Abernathy's isolation
  3. C
    A sympathetic coworker who admires Abernathy's lifelong commitment to the town's historical records
  4. D
    A literal chronicler focused on detailing the sequence of archival sorting tasks performed in the room
  5. E
    An analyst who interprets the dusty sorting room as the primary cause of Abernathy's physical deterioration

Answer

A collective observer whose outward compliance masks a detached and expectant scrutiny of his decline
The correct answer accurately identifies the narrator as a collective observer ('we') whose outward presence as passive colleagues hides their true perspective: a detached, clinical, and expectant interest in the clerk's eventual breakdown rather than admiration for his devotion.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the narrative voice and pronouns used in the passage.
The pronouns 'we' and 'our' establish a first-person plural narrator acting as a group of collective observers.
Determining the narrator's point of view is essential to analyzing their relationship to the characters.
2
Contrast the narrator's internal attitude with the characters' external beliefs.
While Abernathy believes the narrators respect his sacrifice, they state they are actually waiting for his collapse and documenting his decay with cold precision.
This establishes the tension between appearance (respect, diligence) and reality (clinical, detached scrutiny).
3
Evaluate the options to find the description that matches both the collective point of view and the expectant, detached attitude.
The option describing a collective observer with expectant scrutiny matches the first-person plural perspective and their cold observation of the clerk's decline.
Matching textual evidence with option characteristics ensures the selection of the correct answer.

Key Concept

Narrator Identification and Perspective in Short Fiction
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Narrator Identification and Perspective

More questions from this topic