Question

Difficulty: Very hardTone and Mood Analysis

Read the following poem carefully before choosing your answer:

We crossed the salt-flats when the wind was down,
Bearing our shallow jars of oil and grain,
Leaving the dry bones of the lower town
To catch the first cold needles of the rain.
No standard marked our progress, nor did word
Escape the iron circle of our ranks;
Above us wheeled a solitary bird
Whose shadow fell like grease upon the banks.
You called it triumph, that we reached the gate
Before the torches guttered in the frost,
Yet in the silence of the watch-tower's grate,
We could not name the thing we had not lost.
A clean cold wind blew through the empty hall;
We stood like statues, waiting for the fall.

Which of the following best describes the shift in the speaker's attitude over the course of the poem?

  1. from a grimly objective narration of a collective journey to a somber, ironic recognition of their endeavor's futilityAnswer
  2. B
    from the poet’s personal grief over leaving their ancestral home to an objective historical account of a military siege
  3. C
    a uniform and unwavering mood of nostalgic yearning that persists from the initial departure to the final vigil at the gate
  4. D
    an abrupt shift from a celebratory mood, established through the auditory imagery of ranks, to a fearful mood, established through the metaphor of the watch-tower
  5. E
    a progression from despair to hope that occurs strictly at the stanza breaks, ignoring the syntax that flows across the line endings within the stanzas

Answer

The transition in the speaker's attitude is best described as moving from a grimly objective narration of a collective journey to a somber, ironic recognition of their endeavor's futility.
The correct answer accurately identifies the two distinct phases of the speaker's attitude: the initial, grimly objective description of the march, and the subsequent shift in line 9 ('Yet...') to an ironic and disillusioned reflection on the emptiness of their achievement.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the first two stanzas to identify the initial tone and mood established by the speaker.
The setting is described using bleak, unsparing imagery ('salt-flats,' 'dry bones,' 'cold needles of the rain,' 'shadow fell like grease'). The speaker's tone is detached and matter-of-fact, conveying the grim reality of the march without emotional embellishment or self-pity.
Establishing the starting point of the poem's tone is necessary to track any subsequent shifts.
2
Examine the third stanza (lines 9-12) to detect shifts in perspective or attitude.
The speaker introduces a contrast between an external perspective ('You called it triumph') and the group's internal experience ('We could not name the thing we had not lost'). This introduces a highly ironic and reflective tone, questioning the value of their survival or arrival.
Identifying the transitional moment allows for an accurate interpretation of how the speaker's attitude evolves.
3
Analyze the final couplet (lines 13-14) to determine the ultimate tone and mood of the poem.
The final lines present a stark image of stillness ('stood like statues, waiting for the fall') in an empty space, evoking a mood of grim resignation and absolute futility.
The conclusion of the poem solidifies the speaker's final stance, allowing for a comprehensive comparison with the poem's beginning.
4
Synthesize the findings to evaluate the answer choices.
The progression goes from a stark, reportorial description of a bleak journey to an ironic, resigned acknowledgment of a hollow victory. The option describing this movement is the only one that accurately captures both the tonal development and the thematic core of the poem.
Synthesis enables the elimination of distractors that oversimplify the tone, ignore the shift, or conflate the speaker with the author.

Key Concept

Identifying and interpreting shifts in tone and mood in poetry through imagery, syntax, and perspective shifts.
Rate this question