Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardNarrator Identification and Perspective

Read the following passage carefully:

Margaret watched the newcomers from the landing, her hands folded neatly over the banister. How effortlessly they wore their city manners, like garments bought in a shop that morning and destined to be discarded before dusk. There was a performance in the way the younger girl, Florence, tilted her parasol—a calculated angle meant to catch the afternoon sun, or perhaps the eye of someone standing exactly where Margaret stood. How typical of Florence to assume the world was an auditorium constructed solely for her reception. Margaret, of course, was merely an observer, entirely detached from the vanity of their arrivals. She had no interest in the trunk being hauled up the gravel path, nor in the silver monogram that glinted from its leather corner. It was a vulgar display, really, this insistence on bringing the city's heavy luggage into a house that had managed perfectly well with simple pine. When Margaret finally descended to greet them, her smile was as cool and correct as the marble tiles beneath her feet, a silent assertion that she remained untouched by their noisy intrusion.

Which of the following best describes the narrative perspective of the passage?

  1. A
    A first-person participant perspective that allows Margaret to directly justify her resentment toward the visitors.
  2. B
    A third-person omniscient perspective that objectively balances Margaret's inner thoughts with the visitors' actual motivations.
  3. A third-person limited perspective that closely aligns with Margaret's thoughts, revealing her critical attitude while exposing her underlying preoccupation with the visitors.Answer
  4. D
    A third-person limited perspective that uncritically reinforces Margaret's claims of moral superiority and emotional detachment.
  5. E
    A third-person objective perspective that documents Margaret's outer behavior without revealing her internal judgments.

Answer

The narrative perspective of the passage is best described as a third-person limited perspective that closely aligns with Margaret's thoughts, revealing her critical attitude while exposing her underlying preoccupation with the visitors.
The correct answer describes the narration as a third-person limited perspective that aligns with Margaret's thoughts while exposing her preoccupation. The narrative uses third-person pronouns but limits its focus to Margaret's subjective experience. Although Margaret claims to be completely detached and uninterested, her detailed observations of the visitors' parasol, trunk, and silver monogram betray her intense interest and underlying resentment, which the narrator highlights through ironic juxtaposition.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Determine the grammatical person of the narrator by identifying the pronouns used in the passage.
The narrator refers to characters using third-person pronouns ('she', 'her') and names ('Margaret', 'Florence').
This establishes that the narrator is external to the action rather than a first-person narrator.
2
Analyze the extent of the narrator's access to the characters' inner minds.
The narrator reveals Margaret's inner thoughts, silent reactions, and feelings but does not access the internal states of Florence or the other visitors.
This shows the narrative perspective is third-person limited, not omniscient or objective.
3
Evaluate the relationship between Margaret's explicit statements and her observed details to determine the narrator's attitude.
Margaret claims to be 'merely an observer, entirely detached,' yet she notes specific details like the silver monogram and the exact angle of Florence's parasol.
The juxtaposition of Margaret's claimed indifference with her hyper-focus on the visitors reveals that the narrator is exposing her bias and preoccupation through irony, rather than endorsing her claims.

Key Concept

Third-Person Limited Point of View and Narrative Distance
Rate this question

Topics

Narrator Identification and Perspective

More questions from this topic