Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardAllusion and Intertextuality

Read the following poem carefully before answering the question.

The chisel yields to what the frost began,
Chipping the marble down to human form,
Yet leaving rough the shoulder and the hand
To face the onset of the coming storm.
(5) We sculpt our monuments of ancient grief,
And carve the weeping stone to match our own,
But find no solace in the brief relief
Of Niobe’s cold, unyielding, tear-washed throne.
For though she wept until her flesh was rock,
(10) She kept the quiet custody of pain;
While we, who stand before the ticking clock,
Dissolve in silence, wishing for the rain.

In the context of the poem, which of the following best describes the function of the allusion to Niobe (line 8)?

  1. A
    suggest that the speaker’s grief is morally superior to Niobe’s because it does not result in emotional petrification
  2. B
    provide a historical parallel that illustrates the physical process of carving marble statues in ancient Greece
  3. contrast the enduring, unified nature of Niobe’s mythical sorrow with the transient and formless grief experienced by the speakerAnswer
  4. D
    express the poet’s personal desire to escape their contemporary literary career by retreating into classical mythology
  5. E
    retell the myth of Niobe to warn the reader against the dangers of excessive pride and parental hubris

Answer

The correct answer is the option that explains how the allusion contrasts the enduring, unified nature of Niobe’s mythical sorrow with the transient and formless grief experienced by the speaker.
The correct answer is correct because the allusion to Niobe's stone state ('flesh was rock') and her 'quiet custody of pain' illustrates a permanent, monumental form of grief. This stands in direct contrast to the speaker's condition—humans who are subject to 'the ticking clock' and who 'dissolve in silence,' illustrating the formless and fleeting nature of modern human sorrow compared to the enduring stature of myth.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the classical allusion to Niobe and recall her mythological context.
Niobe was turned to stone yet continued to weep for her children, representing a monument of eternal sorrow.
This establishes the literal meaning of the allusion before interpreting its function in the poem.
2
Analyze how the speaker contrasts themselves and modern humans with Niobe.
Niobe 'kept the quiet custody of pain' in her stone form, whereas humans 'stand before the ticking clock' and 'dissolve in silence.'
This reveals the core tension between structural permanence and temporal dissolution.
3
Evaluate the thematic implications of this contrast.
The comparison highlights that while Niobe's grief is permanent and monumental, human grief is temporary and disintegrates over time.
This matches the option describing the contrast between enduring mythical sorrow and transient human grief.

Key Concept

Analyzing the thematic function of classical allusions in poetry to contrast mythological permanence with modern human transience
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Allusion and Intertextuality

More questions from this topic