Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardTone, Voice, and Speaker Persona

Read the following poem carefully before answering the question.

The Cartographer’s Confession

Our borders are but threads of ink we stretch
Across the wilderness we cannot tame;
With compass and with rule we strive to sketch
The wild, unreckoned lands and give them name.
How grandly does the gilded crest declare
The sovereign's reach across the azure main!
Yet wind and tide dismantle what we swear,
And rivers twist to mock our neat domain.
We trace the lines of conquest, bold and neat,
Confining mountain ranges to the page,
While in the dust beneath our mapping feet,
The silent hills outlive the monarch's rage.
I draw the world in lines of gold and blue,
And sell the lie that what I draw is true.

Which of the following best characterizes the shift in the speaker's voice and attitude over the course of the poem?

  1. A
    A shift from initial frustration with natural obstacles to a triumphant celebration of the mapmaker's ultimate dominance over the landscape
  2. B
    A transition from technical descriptions of the cartographic craft to a personal reflection on the poet's own struggles with artistic creation and literary truth
  3. A shift from a collective, professional effort to impose order on nature to a solitary, ironical acknowledgment of complicity in political deceptionAnswer
  4. D
    A consistent defense of imperial expansion that remains straightforwardly sincere and supportive of the sovereign's authority throughout the poem
  5. E
    An identification of the contrast between ink and gold leaf as symbols of class struggles, without connecting these devices to the speaker's internal conflict

Answer

A shift from a collective, professional effort to impose order on nature to a solitary, ironical acknowledgment of complicity in political deception
The correct answer describes the development of the speaker's persona. The poem begins with the collective 'we' representing the cartographic profession trying to sketch and name the wild lands. However, by the final couplet, the speaker shifts to the first-person singular 'I' to make a highly personal and ironical confession: that they draw the world in decorative 'lines of gold and blue' and 'sell the lie' that their maps are true. This shift represents a transition from professional attempts to order the world to a solitary, ironical acknowledgment of complicity in imperial and political deception.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the opening stanza of the poem.
The speaker establishes a collective, professional persona using the pronoun 'we' ('Our borders,' 'we stretch,' 'we strive to sketch'), focusing on the mechanical and logical attempts of cartographers to measure and name the untamable wilderness.
This establishes the initial state of the speaker's voice and attitude.
2
Identify the development and contrast introduced in the second and third stanzas.
The speaker notes that natural forces ('wind and tide,' 'silent hills') dismantle and outlive these artificial boundaries and the 'monarch's rage.' This introduces a tension between imperial claims of control and the enduring reality of nature.
This shows the building of thematic irony and prepares for the shift in voice.
3
Examine the final couplet for a shift in perspective.
The speaker shifts to the singular 'I' ('I draw,' 'what I draw') and explicitly terms their work a 'lie' that is sold. The tone shifts from professional duty and detached observation to intimate, ironical self-awareness of their complicity in projecting false power.
This reveals the ultimate destination of the speaker's voice and attitude.

Key Concept

Tone, Voice, and Speaker Persona
Rate this question

Topics

Tone, Voice, and Speaker Persona

More questions from this topic