Examkin

Question of the Day

A fresh AP English Literature and Composition question every day — build the habit.

Read the following poem carefully before choosing your answer.

1 The iron shears are cold against the vine,
2 A ruthless blade to crop the summer’s state;
3 I sever what was sweet and once divine,
4 And leave the shattered branch to meet its fate.
5 It seems a needless wound we here inflict,
6 To strip the trellised arch of all its shade,
7 And by a winter law, severe and strict,
8 Undo the gentle work the spring had made.
9 But look! Within the dark and frozen wood,
10 The silent sap prepares a brighter birth;
11 This wounding is a promise, understood
12 By those who trust the cycle of the earth.

In the poem, the shift in tone after line 8 ('Undo... made') chiefly reveals a transition from which of the following?

  1. A
    resentment toward the physical demands of labor to satisfaction with a completed chore
  2. B
    literal concern for the survival of the vine to a scientific understanding of botany
  3. sorrow over the apparent destructiveness of winter to reassurance in the promise of future renewalAnswer
  4. D
    frustration with the slow pace of the seasons to a resignation to the inevitability of death
  5. E
    condemnation of human interference with nature to a celebration of human dominance over the wild

Answer

sorrow over the apparent destructiveness of winter to reassurance in the promise of future renewal
The transition from sorrow over the apparent destructiveness of winter to reassurance in the promise of future renewal is correct because lines 1–8 depict pruning as a harsh, damaging act ('ruthless blade,' 'shattered branch,' 'needless wound'), whereas lines 9–12 shift to anticipation of rebirth and growth ('brighter birth,' 'promise').

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the tone and imagery established in the first two quatrains (lines 1–8).
The speaker uses words like 'ruthless,' 'shattered,' 'needless wound,' and 'severe' to describe the pruning of the vine, establishing a sorrowful and regretful tone regarding winter's destruction.
To understand the initial attitude of the speaker before the shift occurs.
2
Analyze the transition and tone in the final quatrain (lines 9–12).
The transition 'But look!' marks a shift to images of regeneration, such as 'brighter birth' and 'promise,' conveying a hopeful and reassured tone.
To identify the speaker's final attitude and how it contrasts with the beginning.
3
Synthesize the contrast to identify the correct thematic transition.
The shift moves from mourning the destruction of the vine in winter to feeling confident in the cyclical renewal of spring.
To match the analyzed shift with the correct option.

Key Concept

Poetic Shifts and Contrasts
See full question & explanationTake a full practice test