Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumAnalyzing Text Structure and Rhetorical Features

Read the following excerpt from a journalistic article about environmental policy in Latin America:

"For decades, Costa Rica’s ecotourism model has been celebrated globally as a triumph of environmental conservation. By prioritizing national parks and sustainable lodging, the country successfully demonstrated that protecting biodiversity could be a lucrative economic strategy. Local communities, once reliant on logging and agriculture, found new, stable sources of income as guides, lodge operators, and conservationists.

Yet, this success has brought its own ecological challenges. In popular destinations, the sheer volume of visitors has led to habitat fragmentation, waste management crises, and the depletion of local aquifers. The rapid construction of hotels and roads, driven by the demand to experience untouched nature, has begun to degrade the very ecosystems that tourists travel to see. Without stricter limits on visitor capacity, the economic engine of conservation risks dismantling its own ecological foundation."

Based on the excerpt provided, what is the primary rhetorical function of the second paragraph in relation to the first paragraph?

  1. A
    It provides specific statistical data to support the economic benefits outlined in the first paragraph.
  2. It qualifies the success described in the first paragraph by introducing the negative ecological consequences of tourism growth.Answer
  3. C
    It outlines a chronological sequence of historical events that led to the creation of Costa Rica's national parks.
  4. D
    It dismisses the conservation efforts described in the first paragraph as entirely ineffective and insincere.

Answer

The option qualifying the success described in the first paragraph by introducing the negative ecological consequences of tourism growth.
The correct answer is correct because the first paragraph introduces the ecotourism model as an absolute success story, while the second paragraph uses the contrastive connector 'Yet' to introduce the negative ecological impacts that qualify or limit this success.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the main idea and tone of the first paragraph.
The first paragraph establishes the positive outcomes and global celebration of Costa Rica's ecotourism model, highlighting its economic and conservation achievements.
This establishes the initial context and thesis that the author will build upon or respond to.
2
Identify the transition word at the start of the second paragraph and analyze the shift in focus.
The second paragraph begins with 'Yet,' signaling a contrast, and describes the negative ecological consequences and challenges arising from that same tourism success.
Analyzing transitions helps determine the logical relationship (contrast, concession, consequence) between different parts of the text.
3
Determine how the second paragraph functions rhetorically to modify the assertions in the first paragraph.
The second paragraph qualifies the absolute success described in the first paragraph by demonstrating that it has unintended negative side effects.
This matches the rhetorical function of qualification, where a writer limits or restricts a previous claim rather than completely dismissing it.

Key Concept

Analyzing paragraph function and rhetorical shifts in journalistic texts.
Rate this question

Topics

Analyzing Text Structure and Rhetorical Features

More questions from this topic