Question

Difficulty: Very hardDistinguishing Fact from Opinion

Listen to the following excerpts from a Spanish audio report regarding a new urban development project. Match each Spanish statement from the audio to the most accurate English description of its epistemological nature (whether it functions as a fact or an opinion, and the sophisticated reasoning behind it).

  • "El documento oficial estipula la creación de diez mil metros cuadrados de áreas verdes."A verifiable, objective detail regarding the project's physical specifications (Fact)
  • "Resulta francamente inaudito que hayamos esperado dos décadas para esta modernización."A subjective evaluation expressing an emotional reaction to the project's timeline (Opinion)
  • "El portavoz de la alcaldía ha declarado que los fondos europeos cubrirán la mitad del coste."An objective report of a claim made by an official, verifying the act of speaking rather than the claim itself (Fact)
  • "Sin lugar a dudas, esta intervención urbana será el motor económico definitivo para nuestra región."A confident, subjective prediction about future outcomes, despite being stated with absolute certainty (Opinion)

Answer

Statement 1 matches the physical specification (Fact), Statement 2 matches the emotional reaction (Opinion), Statement 3 matches the report of an official's claim (Fact), and Statement 4 matches the prediction of outcomes (Opinion).
Each statement from the Spanish audio report utilizes specific rhetorical devices. Statement 1 uses precise numerical data and document referencing, establishing a fact. Statement 2 uses emotive vocabulary ('francamente inaudito'), establishing an opinion. Statement 3 uses journalistic attribution ('ha declarado que'), establishing a factual report of an event. Statement 4 uses absolute language to disguise a future prediction, which remains an opinion.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the first excerpt for subjective markers versus objective data.
The statement cites an official document and a specific measurement ('diez mil metros cuadrados'). There are no value judgments.
Identifying concrete, verifiable data points confirms a statement is an objective fact.
2
Evaluate the vocabulary used in the second excerpt.
The phrase 'Resulta francamente inaudito' expresses disbelief and personal judgment regarding the two-decade wait.
Value-laden adjectives and emotional reactions indicate a subjective opinion, regardless of the underlying truth of the timeline.
3
Examine the journalistic attribution in the third excerpt.
The statement attributes a specific claim to a spokesperson ('ha declarado que').
Reporting that someone made a statement is a verifiable fact, even if the content of their statement contains promises or opinions.
4
Assess the nature of the claim in the fourth excerpt.
Despite the confident introduction 'Sin lugar a dudas', the core message predicts a future outcome ('será el motor económico definitivo').
Future predictions and categorical assessments of success are inherently subjective opinions, even when disguised with language of certainty.

Key Concept

Distinguishing sophisticated markers of fact and opinion in Spanish audio, including attributed statements and disguised predictions.
Rate this question